Kamel A, Chabbou A, el Gharbi B
Service de Pneumophtisiologie, Hôpital Abderrahmane Mami de Pneumophtisiologie de l'Ariana, Tunisie.
Rev Pneumol Clin. 1989;45(3):118-22.
Eosinophilic pleural effusion accounts for 5 to 10% of all clear liquid pleurisies. Its pathogenic significance is unclear and its relation to the causative diagnosis of pleural eosinophilia is diversely evaluated. In this study, 86 cases of eosinophilic pleural effusion observed at the Ariana Pneumophthisiology Hospital over a 5-year period are reviewed. At first aspiration, the proportion of pleural fluid eosinophils varied from 12% to 85% (54% on average). Blood eosinophilia was present in 60% of the patients. The main cause of effusion was tuberculosis (39.6%, but many other diseases were observed; despite numerous investigations, no cause could be found in 23.2% of the cases. The discovery of a pleural eosinophilia has an impact on the probable cause of the pleurisy, and this can be determined by applying Bayes' rule. The probability of tuberculous being the cause falls from 70.3% for clear liquid pleurisies generally to 44.6% for eosinophilic pleurisy. The probability of cancer as a cause falls from 4.5% to 0.66%; whereas that of "idiopathic" pleurisy rises from 13.5% to 59.56%. These findings are concordant with Adelman's conclusions. In other words, the finding of a pleural eosinophilia decreases the probability of tuberculous or malignant pleural effusion and increases the probability of benign or "idiopathic" effusion. Clinicians confronted with an eosinophilic pleural effusion should be particularly careful and accurate since this diagnosis may spare the patient an unnecessary exploratory thoracotomy and an unwarranted antituberculous treatment.
嗜酸性胸腔积液占所有清亮液体性胸膜炎的5%至10%。其致病意义尚不清楚,且其与胸腔嗜酸性粒细胞增多症病因诊断的关系存在多种评估。本研究回顾了在阿丽亚娜肺结核病医院5年期间观察到的86例嗜酸性胸腔积液病例。首次抽液时,胸腔积液嗜酸性粒细胞比例在12%至85%之间(平均54%)。60%的患者存在血液嗜酸性粒细胞增多。积液的主要原因是结核病(39.6%),但也观察到许多其他疾病;尽管进行了大量检查,23.2%的病例仍未发现病因。胸腔嗜酸性粒细胞增多症的发现会影响胸膜炎的可能病因,这可以通过应用贝叶斯法则来确定。结核病作为病因的概率从一般清亮液体性胸膜炎的70.3%降至嗜酸性胸膜炎的44.6%。癌症作为病因的概率从4.5%降至0.66%;而“特发性”胸膜炎的概率从13.5%升至59.56%。这些发现与阿德尔曼的结论一致。换句话说,胸腔嗜酸性粒细胞增多症的发现降低了结核性或恶性胸腔积液的概率,增加了良性或“特发性”积液的概率。面对嗜酸性胸腔积液的临床医生应格外小心和准确,因为这一诊断可能使患者避免不必要的开胸探查和无根据的抗结核治疗。