Mayuoni Kirshenbaum Lina, Benjamin Ofir, Porat Ron
Department of Postharvest Science of Fresh Produce, ARO, The Volcani Center, Bet Dagan, 50250, Israel.
Faculty of Agricultural, Food and Environmental Quality Sciences, Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Rehovot, 76100, Israel.
J Sci Food Agric. 2016 Mar 15;96(4):1313-8. doi: 10.1002/jsfa.7224. Epub 2015 May 29.
The present study aimed to compare the sensory and nutritional attributes of 'Wonderful' pomegranate juices extracted from separated arils with those from pressed whole fruits.
Five different sensory tests were conducted to evaluate the flavor quality of 'Wonderful' pomegranate juices. Consumer acceptance tests revealed that juice from separated arils achieved significantly higher likability scores than that from whole pressed fruits. Furthermore, preference tests revealed that 84% of the tasters preferred the juice extracted from separated arils whereas only 16% preferred the juice from whole pressed fruits. Sensory discrimination tests (triangle tests) revealed that tasters significantly distinguished between the two juices at P ≤ 0.01. Descriptive tests by a trained panel and sensory analysis with an electronic tongue demonstrated that juice from whole pressed fruits was more astringent and had a stronger aftertaste than juice from separated arils. Juice from pressed whole fruits contained significantly higher levels of phenols and hydrolysable tannins, which led to higher astringency.
Pomegranate juice extracted from separated arils was less astringent and more preferred by tasters than juice from whole pressed fruits. Nonetheless, juice from separated arils has lower nutritional benefits.
本研究旨在比较从分离出的石榴籽中提取的“奇妙”石榴汁与从整个压榨果实中提取的石榴汁的感官和营养特性。
进行了五项不同的感官测试来评估“奇妙”石榴汁的风味品质。消费者接受度测试表明,从分离出的石榴籽中提取的果汁的喜好度得分显著高于从整个压榨果实中提取的果汁。此外,偏好测试显示,84%的品尝者更喜欢从分离出的石榴籽中提取的果汁,而只有16%的人更喜欢从整个压榨果实中提取的果汁。感官辨别测试(三角试验)表明,品尝者在P≤0.01时能显著区分这两种果汁。由训练有素的专业小组进行的描述性测试和使用电子舌进行的感官分析表明,从整个压榨果实中提取的果汁比从分离出的石榴籽中提取的果汁更涩,余味更浓。从整个压榨果实中提取的果汁中酚类和可水解单宁的含量显著更高,这导致了更高的涩味。
与从整个压榨果实中提取的果汁相比,从分离出的石榴籽中提取的石榴汁涩味更小,更受品尝者喜爱。然而,从分离出的石榴籽中提取的果汁营养价值较低。