Grondin Francis, Hall Toby, Laurentjoye Mathieu, Ella Bruna
Cranio. 2015 Apr;33(2):91-9. doi: 10.1179/0886963414Z.00000000053. Epub 2014 May 23.
Clinicians increasingly suggest assessment and treatment of the cervical spine in patients with temporomandibular dysfunction (TMD); however, few studies have investigated upper cervical spine mobility in people who suffer from TMD. The purpose of this study was to investigate whether patients with TMD pain (with or without headache) present with upper cervical spine impairment when compared with asymptomatic subjects.
A single blind examiner evaluated cervical range of motion (ROM) measures including axial rotation during the flexion-rotation test (FRT) and sagittal plane ROM. Twenty asymptomatic subjects were compared with 37 subjects with pain attributed to TMD, confirmed by the Revised Research Diagnostic Criteria. Subjects with TMD were divided according to the presence of headache (26 without headache TMDNHA, 11 with headache TMDHA). One-way analysis of variance and planned orthogonal comparisons were used to determine differences in cervical mobility between groups. All subjects with TMD were positive on the FRT with restricted ROM, while none were in the control group.
The analysis of variance revealed significant differences between groups for the FRT F(2,54) = 57.96, P<0.001) and for sagittal ROM [F(2,54) = 5.69, P = 0.006]. Findings show that the TMDHA group had less axial rotation than group TMDNHA, and both TMD groups had less ROM than controls. For sagittal ROM, the only difference was between group TMDHA and controls.
Subjects with TMD had signs of upper cervical spine movement impairment, greater in those with headache. Only subjects with TMD and headache had impairment of cervical spine sagittal plane mobility. This study provides evidence for the importance of examination of upper cervical mobility determined by the FRT in patients who suffer from TMD.
临床医生越来越多地建议对颞下颌关节紊乱病(TMD)患者的颈椎进行评估和治疗;然而,很少有研究调查TMD患者的上颈椎活动度。本研究的目的是调查与无症状受试者相比,患有TMD疼痛(伴或不伴头痛)的患者是否存在上颈椎功能障碍。
一名单盲检查者评估颈椎活动范围(ROM)指标,包括屈曲旋转试验(FRT)期间的轴向旋转和矢状面ROM。将20名无症状受试者与37名经修订的研究诊断标准确诊为TMD疼痛的受试者进行比较。TMD受试者根据是否存在头痛进行分组(26名无头痛的TMD患者,11名有头痛的TMD患者)。采用单因素方差分析和计划正交比较来确定组间颈椎活动度的差异。所有TMD受试者的FRT均为阳性且ROM受限,而对照组均为阴性。
方差分析显示,FRT组间存在显著差异[F(2,54) = 57.96,P<0.001],矢状面ROM也存在显著差异[F(2,54) = 5.69,P = 0.006]。结果表明,有头痛的TMD组的轴向旋转比无头痛的TMD组少,且两个TMD组的ROM均比对照组少。对于矢状面ROM,唯一的差异存在于有头痛的TMD组和对照组之间。
TMD受试者存在上颈椎运动功能障碍的体征,有头痛的患者更为明显。只有患有TMD且有头痛的受试者存在颈椎矢状面活动度障碍。本研究为FRT测定的上颈椎活动度检查在TMD患者中的重要性提供了证据。