Park James D, Kim Edward, Werner Rachel M
Division of General Internal Medicine, Rutgers Robert Wood Johnson Medical School, New Brunswick, NJ, USA.
Department of Computer Science, The College of New Jersey, Ewing, NJ, USA.
J Gen Intern Med. 2015 Nov;30(11):1627-32. doi: 10.1007/s11606-015-3352-0. Epub 2015 May 1.
The range of hospital charges for similar diagnoses show tremendous variability across U.S. hospitals. This charge variability remains unexplained.
We aimed to describe hospital charge variability in the U.S. and examine its relationship to local health factors.
This was a descriptive study of the 2011 Medicare Inpatient Charge data summarizing inpatient hospital charges billed to Medicare. This data was evaluated using 29 county-level measures of health status, health behavior, clinical access and quality, built environment, and socioeconomic status in a clustered, multivariate linear regression.
2871 U.S. hospitals registered with Medicare and with at least ten discharges for diagnosis-related groups (DRGs) of six common inpatient conditions.
Inpatient hospital charges were assessed.
No community health measures were associated with hospital charges. The one notable exception associated with higher charges was higher rates of uninsured status ($344.84 higher charges for every one-percentage point increase in prevalence (p < 0.001)). One variable was associated with lower hospital charges: the percentage of children living in poverty [$309.30 lower charges for every one-percentage point increase in prevalence (p < 0.001)].
Overall, hospital charges lacked an association with population health measures, and their variability remains largely unexplained. However, the association of higher charges with uninsured status raises concerns about hospitals' price-setting strategies, such as price discrimination and cost-shifting strategies that expose vulnerable populations to great financial risks.
美国各医院针对相似诊断的收费范围存在巨大差异。这种收费差异的原因尚不明晰。
我们旨在描述美国医院收费的差异情况,并探究其与当地健康因素之间的关系。
这是一项对2011年医疗保险住院费用数据的描述性研究,该数据汇总了向医疗保险机构收取的住院费用。使用29项县级健康状况、健康行为、临床医疗可及性与质量、建成环境以及社会经济地位指标,通过聚类多元线性回归对这些数据进行评估。
2871家在美国医疗保险机构注册的医院,且针对六种常见住院病症的诊断相关分组(DRGs)至少有十次出院记录。
评估住院费用。
没有社区健康指标与医院收费相关。唯一与较高收费相关的显著例外是未参保率较高(患病率每增加一个百分点,收费高出344.84美元(p < 0.001))。有一个变量与较低的医院收费相关:生活在贫困中的儿童比例(患病率每增加一个百分点,收费降低309.30美元(p < 0.001))。
总体而言,医院收费与人群健康指标缺乏关联,其差异在很大程度上仍无法解释。然而,较高收费与未参保状态之间的关联引发了对医院定价策略的担忧,例如价格歧视和成本转嫁策略,这些策略使弱势群体面临巨大的财务风险。