Tandi Tinyami Erick, Cho YongMin, Akam Aba Jean-Cluade, Afoh Chick Ofilia, Ryu Seung Hun, Choi Min Seok, Kim KyungHee, Choi Jae Wook
Institute for Occupational and Environmental Health, Korea University, Seoul, South Korea.
Ministry of Public Health Yaounde, Yaounde, Cameroon.
Int J Equity Health. 2015 May 12;14:43. doi: 10.1186/s12939-015-0172-0.
Cameroon is classified by the World Health Organization (WHO) as having a critical shortage of health personnel. This is further complicated by the geographic distributional inequalities of the national health workforce. This shortfall impedes Cameroons' progress of improving the human resources for health (HRH) to meet up with the Millennium Development Goals (MDGs) by 2015. However, it is unknown whether the health workforce of Cameroon is distributed equally across geographic regions. Additionally, indicators other than population levels have not been used to measure health care needs. This study aimed to assess the adequacy, evenness of distribution and challenges faced by the health workforce across the different regions of Cameroon.
National health personnel availability and distribution were assessed by use of end-of-year census data for 2011 obtained from the MoPH data base. The inequalities and distribution of the workforce were estimated using Gini coefficient and Lorenz curve and linear regression was used to determine the relation between health personnel density and selected health outcomes. Alternative indicators to determine health care needs were illustrated using concentration curves.
Significant geographic inequalities in the availability of health workforce exist in Cameroon. Some regions have a higher number of physicians (per person) than others leading to poor health outcomes across the regions. 70 % of regions have a density of health personnel-to-population per 1,000 that is less than 1.5, implying acute shortage of health personnel. Poor working and living conditions, coupled with limited opportunities for career progress accounted for some documented 232 physicians and 205 nurses that migrated from the public sector. Significant distributional inequality was noticed when under-five infant mortality and malaria prevalence rate were used as indicators to measure health care needs.
Our results show an absolute shortage of public health personnel in Cameroon that is further complicated by the geographic distributional inequalities across the regions of the nation. Cameroon aims to achieve universal health coverage by 2035; to realize this objective, policies targeting training, recruitment, retention and effective deployment of motivated and supported health workforce as well as the development and improvement of health infrastructures remain the major challenge.
世界卫生组织(WHO)将喀麦隆列为卫生人员严重短缺的国家。该国卫生人力的地理分布不平等使这一情况更加复杂。这种短缺阻碍了喀麦隆在到2015年改善卫生人力资源(HRH)以实现千年发展目标(MDGs)方面取得进展。然而,喀麦隆的卫生人力在各地理区域的分布是否均衡尚不清楚。此外,尚未使用人口水平以外的指标来衡量医疗保健需求。本研究旨在评估喀麦隆不同地区卫生人力的充足性、分布均匀性以及所面临的挑战。
通过使用从公共卫生部数据库获取的2011年年终普查数据,评估全国卫生人员的可获得性和分布情况。使用基尼系数和洛伦兹曲线估计劳动力的不平等和分布情况,并使用线性回归确定卫生人员密度与选定的健康结果之间的关系。使用集中曲线说明了用于确定医疗保健需求的替代指标。
喀麦隆卫生人力的可获得性存在显著的地理不平等。一些地区的医生人数(人均)高于其他地区,导致各地区的健康结果不佳。70%的地区每1000人的卫生人员密度低于1.5,这意味着卫生人员严重短缺。工作和生活条件差,再加上职业发展机会有限,导致约232名医生和205名护士从公共部门离职。当将五岁以下婴儿死亡率和疟疾患病率用作衡量医疗保健需求的指标时,发现了显著的分布不平等。
我们的结果表明,喀麦隆公共卫生人员绝对短缺,而且该国各地区的地理分布不平等使这一情况更加复杂。喀麦隆的目标是到2035年实现全民健康覆盖;为实现这一目标,针对培训、招聘、留住和有效部署积极且得到支持的卫生人力以及发展和改善卫生基础设施的政策仍然是主要挑战。