智能手机和平板设备在手术中的应用:文献系统综述
The uses of smartphones and tablet devices in surgery: A systematic review of the literature.
作者信息
Mobasheri Mohammad H, Johnston Maximilian, Syed Usama M, King Dominic, Darzi Ara
机构信息
Department of Surgery & Cancer, Imperial College London, London, UK.
Institute of Global Health Innovation, Imperial College London, London, UK.
出版信息
Surgery. 2015 Nov;158(5):1352-71. doi: 10.1016/j.surg.2015.03.029. Epub 2015 May 9.
BACKGROUND
Smartphones and tablet devices have become ubiquitous, and their adoption in the health care arena is growing. Reviews have looked at their utilities within medical specialties. Despite the many surgical apps available currently, there has not been a comprehensive literature review evaluating uses of these platforms within surgical disciplines. We reviewed the literature systematically in this regard.
METHODS
Embase, MEDLINE, Health Management Informatics Consortium, and PsychINFO databases were searched for empiric quantitative studies evaluating interventions based in the use of smartphone or tablet device within surgical disciplines targeted at surgeons, patients, or the wider public.
RESULTS
Of the 39 studies included, 24 evaluated smartphone-based interventions and 15 looked at tablet devices, whereas 30 were app-based interventions and 9 were not. A wide range of effective and innovative utilities were identified and categorized into 8 domains; Diagnostics (n = 11), telemedicine (n = 9), operative navigation (n = 6), training (n = 5), data collection (n = 3), patient education (n = 2), behavior change (n = 2), and operative planning (n = 1).
CONCLUSION
This comprehensive systematic literature review of smartphone and tablet device use in surgery demonstrates a wide range of innovative utilities in the pre-, intra-, and postoperative contexts. Although results of individual studies generally were favorable, limitations in methodologies existed in many, and although studies clearly highlight the substantial potential of smartphone and tablet devices in the surgical setting, trials of greater quality will be necessary to pave the way for their widespread adoption.
背景
智能手机和平板设备已无处不在,它们在医疗保健领域的应用也在不断增加。已有综述探讨了它们在医学专科中的效用。尽管目前有许多手术应用程序,但尚未有全面的文献综述评估这些平台在外科领域的应用。我们在这方面进行了系统的文献综述。
方法
检索了Embase、MEDLINE、卫生管理信息学联盟和PsychINFO数据库,以查找基于经验的定量研究,这些研究评估了针对外科医生、患者或更广泛公众的外科领域中使用智能手机或平板设备的干预措施。
结果
在纳入的39项研究中,24项评估了基于智能手机的干预措施,15项研究了平板设备,其中30项是基于应用程序的干预措施,9项不是。确定了广泛的有效和创新效用,并将其分为8个领域:诊断(n = 11)、远程医疗(n = 9)、手术导航(n = 6)、培训(n = 5)、数据收集(n = 3)、患者教育(n = 2)、行为改变(n = 2)和手术规划(n = 1)。
结论
这项关于智能手机和平板设备在手术中应用的全面系统文献综述表明,在术前、术中和术后环境中具有广泛的创新效用。尽管个别研究结果总体上是有利的,但许多研究在方法上存在局限性,而且尽管研究清楚地突出了智能手机和平板设备在手术环境中的巨大潜力,但仍需要更高质量的试验为其广泛应用铺平道路。