Bottner R K, Green C E, Ewels C J, Recientes E, Patrissi G A, Kent K M
Division of Cardiology, Georgetown University Hospital, Washington, DC 20007.
Circulation. 1989 Dec;80(6):1580-4. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.80.6.1580.
Of 1,181 consecutive patients who underwent successful percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (PTCA) as an initial revascularization procedure and who had at least 1 year of asymptomatic follow-up, 66 (6%) underwent repeat angiography because of recurrent symptoms or evidence of exercise-induced ischemia. Patients who had revascularization procedures within 1 year of PTCA were not included in the analysis. Mean time to recurrent ischemia was 30.8 +/- 17.4 months (range 12-89 months). At follow-up, 47 patients had angina, 13 had atypical chest pain, two had acute myocardial infarction, and four had positive exercise tests without symptoms. No patient showed spontaneous regression in the extent of coronary artery disease (CAD). As compared with the extent of CAD immediately after PTCA, the extent of CAD at follow-up did not change in 26 patients (39%); it increased by one vessel in 30 (45%), by two vessels in seven (11%), and by three vessels in three (5%). The pattern of CAD seen at follow-up compared with that seen after PTCA was as follows: 18 patients (27%), no change; seven (11%), restenosis only; 30 (45%), progression of CAD at other sites only; and 11 (17%), a combination of restenosis and progression of CAD at other sites. The time to recurrence of ischemia was significantly different between those with restenosis only versus those with progression only (20.1 +/- 9.2 vs. 38.3 +/- 18.5 months) (p less than 0.009). Progression of CAD was equally distributed between dilated and nondilated vessels; however, when progression occurred in the PTCA vessel, it was significantly more likely to be distal to the PTCA site (p less than 0.008).
在1181例连续接受成功的经皮腔内冠状动脉成形术(PTCA)作为初始血运重建手术且至少有1年无症状随访的患者中,66例(6%)因复发症状或运动诱发缺血的证据而接受了重复血管造影。PTCA术后1年内接受血运重建手术的患者未纳入分析。复发缺血的平均时间为30.8±17.4个月(范围12 - 89个月)。随访时,47例患者有胸痛,13例有非典型胸痛,2例有急性心肌梗死,4例运动试验阳性但无症状。没有患者显示冠状动脉疾病(CAD)范围自发缩小。与PTCA后即刻的CAD范围相比,随访时26例患者(39%)的CAD范围未改变;30例(45%)增加了1支血管,7例(11%)增加了2支血管,3例(5%)增加了3支血管。随访时所见的CAD模式与PTCA后所见模式如下:18例患者(27%),无变化;7例(11%),仅再狭窄;30例(45%),仅其他部位CAD进展;11例(17%),再狭窄与其他部位CAD进展并存。仅再狭窄患者与仅进展患者之间缺血复发时间有显著差异(20.1±9.2 vs. 38.3±18.5个月)(p<0.009)。CAD进展在扩张血管和未扩张血管中分布相同;然而,当PTCA血管发生进展时,更可能发生在PTCA部位的远端(p<0.008)。