Hopfner Franziska, Erhart Tatjana, Knudsen Karina, Lorenz Delia, Schneider Susanne A, Zeuner Kirsten E, Deuschl Günther, Kuhlenbäumer Gregor
Department of Neurology, University Hospital Schleswig-Holstein, Campus Kiel, Kiel, Germany.
Department of Neurology, University Hospital Schleswig-Holstein, Campus Kiel, Kiel, Germany.
Parkinsonism Relat Disord. 2015 Aug;21(8):848-51. doi: 10.1016/j.parkreldis.2015.05.005. Epub 2015 May 14.
Improvement of essential tremor (ET) amplitude after alcohol ingestion is usually based on patient reports but a quantitative test for large numbers of patients is lacking and the percentage of ET patients with a detectable alcohol effect is therefore unknown.
A validated and published alcohol home test was used in 104 ET patients. The Archimedes spiral was drawn before alcohol ingestion and at 4 time points after alcohol consumption and rated on a 10-point rating scale according to Bain and Findley. A second identical test without alcohol ingestion was performed by the same patients and evaluated by the same two raters to analyze the total variability of the spiral ratings.
Alcohol reduces tremor in ET patients as a group and a rebound effect with an increase in tremor intensity was found the next morning. Sex, family history of ET, diagnosis (definite vs. probable) and medical history of alcohol responsiveness do not predict the alcohol response. The minimal detectable difference in the spiral score was 2 due to spontaneous tremor fluctuations and inter-rater differences. The test demonstrated alcohol sensitivity of the tremor in 46% of the patients. Responsivity to alcohol could only be seen in patients with spiral scores above 3.
Alcohol sensitivity is a feature of ET in at least 46% of the patients. We could not find predictors for alcohol sensitivity. The minimal detectable change is 2 scores and alcohol responsivity was only detected in patients with baseline Archimedes spiral rating of ≥3.
酒精摄入后特发性震颤(ET)振幅的改善通常基于患者报告,但缺乏针对大量患者的定量测试,因此ET患者中可检测到酒精效应的百分比尚不清楚。
对104例ET患者使用经过验证并已发表的酒精家庭测试。在摄入酒精前以及摄入酒精后的4个时间点绘制阿基米德螺旋线,并根据贝恩和芬德利的10分制评分量表进行评分。同一名患者进行第二次相同的不摄入酒精的测试,并由相同的两名评估者进行评估,以分析螺旋线评分的总体变异性。
酒精可减轻ET患者群体的震颤,并且在第二天早晨发现有震颤强度增加的反弹效应。性别、ET家族史、诊断(确诊与疑似)以及酒精反应性病史均不能预测酒精反应。由于自发震颤波动和评估者间差异,螺旋线评分的最小可检测差异为2。该测试显示46%的患者震颤对酒精敏感。仅在螺旋线评分高于3的患者中可观察到对酒精的反应性。
酒精敏感性是至少46%的ET患者的一个特征。我们未找到酒精敏感性的预测因素。最小可检测变化为2分,且仅在基线阿基米德螺旋线评分为≥3的患者中检测到酒精反应性。