Senthilkumar Chinnu Sugavanam, Akhter Sameena, Malla Tahir Mohiuddin, Sah Nand Kishore, Ganesh Narayanan
Clinical Cytogenetics Laboratory, Department of Research, Jawaharlal Nehru Cancer Hospital and Research Centre, Bhopal, Madhya Pradesh, India E-mail :
Asian Pac J Cancer Prev. 2015;16(10):4409-19. doi: 10.7314/apjcp.2015.16.10.4409.
The Bhopal gas tragedy involving methyl isocyanate (MIC) is one of the most horrific industrial accidents in recent decades. We investigated the genotoxic effects of MIC in long-term survivors and their offspring born after the 1984 occurrence. There are a few cytogenetic reports showing genetic damage in the MIC-exposed survivors, but there is no information about the associated cancer risk. The same is true about offspring. For the first time, we here assessed the micronucleus (MN) frequency using cytokinesis-blocked micronucleus (CBMN) assay to predict cancer risk in the MIC-affected population of Bhopal. A total of 92 healthy volunteers (46 MIC- affected and 46 controls) from Bhopal and various regions of India were studied taking gender and age into consideration. Binucleated lymphocytes with micronuclei (BNMN), total number of micronuclei in lymphocytes (MNL), and nuclear division index (NDI) frequencies and their relationship to age, gender and several lifestyle variabilities (smoking, alcohol consumption and tobacco-chewing) were investigated. Our observations showed relatively higher BNMN and MNL (P<0.05) in the MIC-affected than in the controls. Exposed females (EF) exhibited significantly higher BNMN and MNL (P<0.01) than their unexposed counterparts. Similarly, female offspring of the exposed (FOE) also suffered higher BNMN and MNL (P<0.05) than in controls. A significant reduction in NDI (P<0.05) was found only in EF. The affected group of non-smokers and non-alcoholics featured a higher frequency of BNMN and MNL than the control group of non-smokers and non-alcoholics (P<0.01). Similarly, the affected group of tobacco chewers showed significantly higher BNMN and MNL (P<0.001) than the non-chewers. Amongst the affected, smoking and alcohol consumption were not associated with statistically significant differences in BNMN, MNL and NDI. Nevertheless, tobacco-chewing had a preponderant effect with respect to MNL. A reasonable correlation between MNL and lifestyle habits (smoking, alcohol consumption and tobacco-chewing) was observed only in the controls. Our results suggest that EF and FOE are more susceptible to cancer development, as compared to EM and MOE. The genotoxic outcome detected in FOE reflects their parental exposure to MIC. Briefly, the observed cytogenetic damage to the MIC-affected could contribute to cancer risk, especially in the EF and FOE.
涉及甲基异氰酸酯(MIC)的博帕尔毒气悲剧是近几十年来最可怕的工业事故之一。我们调查了MIC对长期幸存者及其1984年事故后出生的后代的遗传毒性影响。有一些细胞遗传学报告显示,接触MIC的幸存者存在遗传损伤,但尚无关于相关癌症风险的信息。后代的情况也是如此。我们首次在此使用胞质分裂阻滞微核(CBMN)试验评估微核(MN)频率,以预测博帕尔受MIC影响人群的癌症风险。考虑到性别和年龄,对来自博帕尔和印度不同地区的92名健康志愿者(46名受MIC影响者和46名对照者)进行了研究。研究了带有微核的双核淋巴细胞(BNMN)、淋巴细胞中微核的总数(MNL)、核分裂指数(NDI)频率及其与年龄、性别和几种生活方式变量(吸烟、饮酒和嚼烟)的关系。我们的观察结果显示,受MIC影响者的BNMN和MNL相对较高(P<0.05),高于对照组。暴露女性(EF)的BNMN和MNL显著高于未暴露的女性(P<0.01)。同样,暴露女性的后代(FOE)的BNMN和MNL也高于对照组(P<0.05)。仅在EF中发现NDI显著降低(P<0.05)。不吸烟且不饮酒的受影响组的BNMN和MNL频率高于不吸烟且不饮酒的对照组(P<0.01)。同样,嚼烟的受影响组的BNMN和MNL显著高于不嚼烟者(P<0.001)。在受影响者中,吸烟和饮酒与BNMN、MNL和NDI的统计学显著差异无关。然而,嚼烟对MNL有显著影响。仅在对照组中观察到MNL与生活方式习惯(吸烟、饮酒和嚼烟)之间存在合理的相关性。我们的结果表明,与暴露男性(EM)和未暴露男性的后代(MOE)相比,EF和FOE更容易患癌症。在FOE中检测到的遗传毒性结果反映了他们的父母接触过MIC。简而言之,观察到的受MIC影响者的细胞遗传学损伤可能会增加癌症风险,尤其是在EF和FOE中。