Fanigliulo A, Viggiano A, Gualco A, Crescenzi A
Commun Agric Appl Biol Sci. 2014;79(3):433-7.
Tomato spotted wilt disease is caused by Tomato Spotted Wilt Virus (TSWV) (Tospovirus, Bunyaviridae), a virus that severely damages and reduces the yield of many economically important plants worldwide and actually it is a major disease affecting the production of tomato and pepper in Italy. Due to the non-predictive nature of its outbreaks combined with the lack of forecasting, adoption of preventive measures have not always been practical, in fact the disease cycle has proven to be extremely difficult to break because of the wide and often overlapping host range of both the virus and the thrips vectors, which transmit the virus in a persistent, circulative, and propagative manner. Moreover recently, resistance breaking (RB) isolates of TSWV that overcome the resistance conferred by the Tsw gene in different pepper hybrids have been recovered in different locations in Italy and also in Brazil, USA, Spain and Australia, and this occurrence raises the question on the importance of a new approach of integrated pest management for TSWV management, including both control of its insect vector and the induction of the plant's resistance against viral infection. In this perspective, a study was performed in 2012 and 2013 with the purpose of evaluating the efficacy of the insecticide Cyantraniliprole alone or combined with Acibenzolar-S-Methyl (ASM), inducer of systemic acquired resistance, in the control of tomato spotted wilt disease in pepper. The experiment was performed in laboratory, in a thermo-conditioned greenhouse, into separate insect-proof cages and consisted of 5 treatments and 2 applications (plus a pre-transplant application for treatments were ASM was used. Variables were the mode of application of ASM in pre-transplant (by foliar or by drench) and the duration of the exposure time of the treated plants to viruliferous insects. Pepper cv. Corno di Toro, devoid of any resistance to TSWV, was used. Plants were observed daily to record any symptom induced by TSWV and/or of phytotoxicity. The possible TSWV infection was verified by DAS-ELISA using antisera supplied by Agdia Biofords. It was shown that the combination of ASM and Cyantraniliprole allowed the best control of TSWV transmission by thrips and of the development of the infection in treated pepper plants, regardless of the exposure time to thrips infestation. The application via drench of the combination seems to be the most effective. The efficacy of Cyantraniliprole used alone was comparable to that obtained with its combination with ASM only when plants were exposed to viruliferous insects for 24 h after product application, and the effectiveness of protection decreased with increasing time of exposure to viruliferous thrips. Treatment with ASM alone determined a good protection to plants regardless of the length of the exposure timing to viruliferous insects, with a smaller number of infected plants and milder symptoms compared to the check. Results of our current experiments raise the interesting possibility to combine in one product an insecticide and a non-specific (to various biotic and abiotic stresses) resistance inducer, particularly against diseases caused by viruses, and offer great opportunity for the integrated pest management (IPM) strategy for the control of pepper diseases.
番茄斑萎病由番茄斑萎病毒(TSWV)(番茄斑萎病毒属,布尼亚病毒科)引起,该病毒严重损害并降低了全球许多经济重要性植物的产量,实际上它是影响意大利番茄和辣椒生产的主要病害。由于其爆发具有不可预测性,再加上缺乏预测手段,采取预防措施并不总是可行的。事实上,由于病毒和蓟马传播媒介的宿主范围广泛且常常重叠,而蓟马以持久、循环和增殖的方式传播病毒,因此已证明该病的循环极难打破。此外,最近在意大利的不同地点以及巴西、美国、西班牙和澳大利亚都发现了能克服不同辣椒杂交品种中Tsw基因所赋予抗性的TSWV抗性突破(RB)分离株,这种情况引发了关于采用新的综合虫害管理方法来防治TSWV的重要性的问题,该方法包括控制其昆虫传播媒介以及诱导植物对病毒感染的抗性。从这个角度来看,2012年和2013年进行了一项研究,目的是评估杀虫剂氰虫酰胺单独使用或与系统获得性抗性诱导剂烯丙苯噻唑(ASM)联合使用对辣椒中番茄斑萎病的防治效果。该实验在实验室的控温温室中,置于单独的防虫笼内进行,包括5种处理和2次施药(对于使用ASM的处理还包括一次移植前施药)。变量包括移植前ASM的施药方式(叶面喷施或灌根)以及处理过的植株暴露于带毒昆虫的时间长度。使用了对TSWV无任何抗性的辣椒品种“科诺迪托罗”。每天观察植株,记录由TSWV诱导的任何症状和/或植物毒性。通过使用Agdia Biofords提供的抗血清进行双抗夹心酶联免疫吸附测定(DAS - ELISA)来验证是否可能感染TSWV。结果表明,无论植株暴露于蓟马侵染的时间长短,ASM和氰虫酰胺的组合对蓟马传播TSWV以及处理过的辣椒植株中感染的发展具有最佳的防治效果。组合药剂灌根施用似乎最为有效。仅当植株在施药后24小时暴露于带毒昆虫时,单独使用氰虫酰胺的效果与它和ASM联合使用时相当,并且随着暴露于带毒蓟马时间增加,保护效果会下降。单独使用ASM处理对植株有良好的保护作用,无论暴露于带毒昆虫的时间长短,与对照相比,感染植株数量更少且症状更轻。我们当前实验的结果提出了一种有趣的可能性,即将一种杀虫剂和一种对各种生物和非生物胁迫非特异性的抗性诱导剂组合在一种产品中,特别是针对由病毒引起的病害,这为辣椒病害防治的综合虫害管理(IPM)策略提供了巨大机遇。