Lobo Jorge, Teixeira Marcos A L, Borges Luisa M S, Ferreira Maria S G, Hollatz Claudia, Gomes Pedro T, Sousa Ronaldo, Ravara Ascensão, Costa Maria H, Costa Filipe O
CBMA - Centre of Molecular and Environmental Biology, Departamento de Biologia, Universidade do Minho, Campus de Gualtar, 4710-057, Braga, Portugal.
MARE - Marine and Environmental Sciences Centre, Departamento de Ciências e Engenharia do Ambiente, Faculdade de Ciências e Tecnologia da Universidade Nova de Lisboa, 2829-516, Monte de Caparica, Portugal.
Mol Ecol Resour. 2016 Jan;16(1):298-313. doi: 10.1111/1755-0998.12441. Epub 2015 Jul 21.
Annelid polychaetes have been seldom the focus of dedicated DNA barcoding studies, despite their ecological relevance and often dominance, particularly in soft-bottom estuarine and coastal marine ecosystems. Here, we report the first assessment of the performance of DNA barcodes in the discrimination of shallow water polychaete species from the southern European Atlantic coast, focusing on specimens collected in estuaries and coastal ecosystems of Portugal. We analysed cytochrome oxidase I DNA barcodes (COI-5P) from 164 specimens, which were assigned to 51 morphospecies. To our data set from Portugal, we added available published sequences selected from the same species, genus or family, to inspect for taxonomic congruence among studies and collection location. The final data set comprised 290 specimens and 79 morphospecies, which generated 99 Barcode Index Numbers (BINs) within Barcode of Life Data Systems (BOLD). Among these, 22 BINs were singletons, 47 other BINs were concordant, confirming the initial identification based on morphological characters, and 30 were discordant, most of which consisted on multiple BINs found for the same morphospecies. Some of the most prominent cases in the latter category include Hediste diversicolor (O.F. Müller, 1776) (7), Eulalia viridis (Linnaeus, 1767) (2) and Owenia fusiformis (delle Chiaje, 1844) (5), all of them reported from Portugal and frequently used in ecological studies as environmental quality indicators. Our results for these species showed discordance between molecular lineages and morphospecies, or added additional relatively divergent lineages. The potential inaccuracies in environmental assessments, where underpinning polychaete species diversity is poorly resolved or clarified, demand additional and extensive investigation of the DNA barcode diversity in this group, in parallel with alpha taxonomy efforts.
尽管环节动物多毛纲动物具有生态相关性且常常占据优势,特别是在软底河口和沿海海洋生态系统中,但它们很少成为专门的DNA条形码研究的焦点。在此,我们报告了首次对DNA条形码在鉴别来自南欧大西洋海岸的浅水多毛纲物种方面的性能评估,重点关注在葡萄牙河口和沿海生态系统中采集的标本。我们分析了164个标本的细胞色素氧化酶I DNA条形码(COI-5P),这些标本被归为51个形态物种。我们将从相同物种、属或科中选择的已发表可用序列添加到我们来自葡萄牙的数据集,以检查不同研究和采集地点之间的分类一致性。最终数据集包括290个标本和79个形态物种,在生命条形码数据系统(BOLD)中产生了99个条形码索引号(BINs)。其中,22个BINs是单例,47个其他BINs是一致的,证实了基于形态特征的初始鉴定,30个是不一致的,其中大多数是同一形态物种发现多个BINs。后一类中一些最突出的例子包括多变钩沙蚕(O.F. Müller,1776)(7个)、绿欧氏虫(林奈,1767)(2个)和纺锤欧文虫(delle Chiaje,1844)(5个),所有这些都来自葡萄牙,并且在生态研究中经常被用作环境质量指标。我们对这些物种的研究结果表明分子谱系和形态物种之间存在不一致,或者增加了其他相对不同的谱系。在底栖多毛纲物种多样性未得到很好解析或阐明的环境评估中,潜在的不准确之处要求在进行α分类学工作的同时,对该类群的DNA条形码多样性进行额外的广泛研究。