Mischel Maria, Esper Jan, Keppler Frank, Greule Markus, Werner Willy
a Department of Geography , Johannes Gutenberg University , Mainz , Germany.
b Department of Geobotany , University of Trier , Trier , Germany.
Isotopes Environ Health Stud. 2015;51(4):553-68. doi: 10.1080/10256016.2015.1056181. Epub 2015 Jul 8.
Novel tree ring parameters - δ(13)C and δ(2)H from methoxyl groups - have been developed to reconstruct palaeoclimate. Tests with δ(13)C and δ(18)O derived from whole wood and cellulose samples, however, indicated differences in the isotopic composition and climate signal, depending on the extracted wood component. We assess this signal dependency by analysing (i) δ(13)C and δ(18)O from whole wood and cellulose and (ii) δ(13)C and δ(2)H from methoxyl groups, using Pinus sylvestris L. growing near Altenkirchen (Germany). Results indicate significant correlations among the time series derived from whole wood, cellulose, and lignin methoxyl groups. Compared with the whole wood samples, δ(13)C from methoxyl groups showed a different and overall lower response to climate parameters. On the other hand, δ(2)H from methoxyl groups showed high correlations with temperature and was also correlated with ring width, indicating its potential as a temperature proxy. Isotope time series with the highest correlation with climatic parameter were: (i) whole wood and cellulose δ(13)C with growing season precipitation and summer temperature; (ii) methoxyl groups with spring precipitation; (iii) whole wood and cellulose δ(18)O correlates with annual evapotranspiration and water balance; and (iv) methoxyl group δ(2)H with spring temperatures. These findings reveal that multiple climate elements can be reconstructed from different wood components and that whole wood proxies perform comparably to cellulose time series.
新型树轮参数——来自甲氧基的δ(13)C和δ(2)H——已被开发用于重建古气候。然而,对来自全木和纤维素样本的δ(13)C和δ(18)O的测试表明,根据提取的木材成分不同,同位素组成和气候信号存在差异。我们通过分析(i)全木和纤维素中的δ(13)C和δ(18)O以及(ii)使用生长在德国阿尔滕基兴附近的欧洲赤松,分析甲氧基中的δ(13)C和δ(2)H来评估这种信号依赖性。结果表明,来自全木、纤维素和木质素甲氧基的时间序列之间存在显著相关性。与全木样本相比,甲氧基中的δ(13)C对气候参数表现出不同且总体较低的响应。另一方面,甲氧基中的δ(2)H与温度高度相关,并且也与年轮宽度相关,表明其作为温度代理的潜力。与气候参数相关性最高的同位素时间序列为:(i)全木和纤维素δ(13)C与生长季降水量和夏季温度;(ii)甲氧基与春季降水量;(iii)全木和纤维素δ(18)O与年蒸散量和水平衡相关;以及(iv)甲氧基δ(2)H与春季温度。这些发现表明,可以从不同的木材成分重建多种气候要素,并且全木代理与纤维素时间序列表现相当。