Zahra N, Monnet C, Bartha E, Bouilhol G, Boydev C, Courbis M, Le Grévellec M, Bosset M, Zouai M, Fleury B, Clippe S
Centre de radiothérapie Marie-Curie, 159, boulevard Maréchal-Juin, 26000 Valence, France.
Centre de radiothérapie Marie-Curie, 159, boulevard Maréchal-Juin, 26000 Valence, France.
Cancer Radiother. 2015 Aug;19(5):303-7. doi: 10.1016/j.canrad.2015.04.002. Epub 2015 Jul 21.
This work evaluated the interobserver variability in cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) registration for prostate cancers treated with intensity-modulated radiotherapy.
Twelve technologists realized 286 CBCT/CT registrations (bone registration followed by prostate to prostate registration). The registration results were compared to those obtained by two radiation oncologists (reference). Each technologist reported the shifts calculated by the software in all three axes. A statistical analysis allowed us to calculate the minimum threshold under which 95% of the observers found similar values. A variance analysis followed by the post hoc test were used to find differences in interobserver registration variability and determine whether any individual users performed registrations which differed significantly from those of the other users.
The registration differences compared to the reference in the three directions in terms of 95th percentile are: 2.1mm left-right, 3.5mm target-gun, 7.3mm anterior-posterior. In the posterior direction, 4% of the observers have found differences superior to 8mm, margin used in routine without the use of a daily CBCT. The variance test revealed a P-value <0.05 only for target-gun and for all observers there was no significant difference compared to the reference.
This study confirmed the interest of a 3D tissue registration for prostate treatments. The registration study showed a good interobserver reproducibility. This showed the importance of a daily CBCT/CT registration in prostate treatment with the possibility of a planning target volume margin reduction in the three directions. An evaluation of a partial delegation of registration to technologists should be done by the radiation oncologists.
本研究评估了在调强放射治疗的前列腺癌锥形束计算机断层扫描(CBCT)配准中观察者间的变异性。
12名技术人员完成了286次CBCT/CT配准(先进行骨配准,然后进行前列腺到前列腺的配准)。将配准结果与两名放射肿瘤学家获得的结果(作为参考)进行比较。每位技术人员报告软件在三个轴向上计算出的位移。通过统计分析,我们计算出了95%的观察者发现相似值的最小阈值。采用方差分析及事后检验来发现观察者间配准变异性的差异,并确定是否有任何个体用户的配准结果与其他用户有显著差异。
与参考值相比,在三个方向上第95百分位数的配准差异为:左右方向2.1毫米,靶区-射野方向3.5毫米,前后方向7.3毫米。在前后方向上,4%的观察者发现差异超过8毫米,这是常规情况下不使用每日CBCT时所采用的边界值。方差检验仅在靶区-射野方向显示P值<0.05,并且与参考值相比,所有观察者之间没有显著差异。
本研究证实了三维组织配准在前列腺治疗中的价值。配准研究显示了良好的观察者间可重复性。这表明了每日CBCT/CT配准在前列腺治疗中的重要性,以及在三个方向上有可能减少计划靶区边界。放射肿瘤学家应评估将部分配准工作委托给技术人员的可行性。