Ciplak Nesli
a Department of Environmental Engineering, Faculty of Engineering , University of Karabuk , Karabuk , Turkey.
J Air Waste Manag Assoc. 2015 Aug;65(8):919-29. doi: 10.1080/10962247.2015.1038398.
The aim of this paper is to identify the best possible health care waste management option in the West Black Sea Region by taking into account economic, social, environmental, and technical aspects in the concept of multi-criteria decision analysis. In the scope of this research, three different health care waste management scenarios that consist of different technology alternatives were developed and compared using a decision-making computer software, called Right Choice, by identifying various criteria, measuring them, and ranking their relative importance from the point of key stakeholders. The results of the study show that the decentralized autoclave technology option coupled with the disposal through land-filling with energy recovery has potential to be an optimum option for health care waste management system, and an efficient health care waste segregation scheme should be given more attention by the authorities in the region. Furthermore, the discussion of the results points out multidisciplinary approach and the equilibrium between social, environmental, economic, and technical criteria. The methodology used in this research was developed in order to enable the decision makers to gain an increased perception of a decision problem. In general, the results and remarks of this study can be used as a basis of future planning and anticipation of needs for investment in the area of health care waste management in the region and also in developing countries that are dealing with the similar waste management problems.
本文旨在通过在多标准决策分析概念中考虑经济、社会、环境和技术方面,确定西黑海地区最佳的医疗保健废物管理方案。在本研究范围内,开发了三种不同的医疗保健废物管理方案,这些方案由不同的技术替代方案组成,并使用名为“正确选择”的决策计算机软件进行比较,通过确定各种标准、对其进行衡量并从关键利益相关者的角度对其相对重要性进行排名。研究结果表明,分散式高压灭菌技术方案与通过填埋进行处置并回收能源相结合,有可能成为医疗保健废物管理系统的最佳选择,该地区的当局应更加重视高效的医疗保健废物分类方案。此外,对结果的讨论指出了多学科方法以及社会、环境、经济和技术标准之间的平衡。本研究中使用的方法是为了使决策者能够更好地理解决策问题而开发的。总体而言,本研究的结果和评论可作为该地区以及处理类似废物管理问题的发展中国家未来规划和预测医疗保健废物管理领域投资需求的基础。