Schumm Jeremiah A, Dickstein Benjamin D, Walter Kristen H, Owens Gina P, Chard Kathleen M
Cincinnati VA Medical Center.
Health and Behavioral Sciences, Naval Health Research Center, San Diego.
J Consult Clin Psychol. 2015 Dec;83(6):1161-6. doi: 10.1037/ccp0000040. Epub 2015 Jul 27.
Although cognitive processing therapy (CPT) has strong empirical support as a treatment for posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD), studies have not directly examined the proposed change mechanisms that underlie CPT-that change in trauma-related cognitions produces change in PTSD and depression symptoms. To improve the understanding of underlying mechanisms of psychotherapeutic change, this study investigated longitudinal association between trauma-related cognitions, PTSD, and depression among veterans receiving CPT during a 7-week residential PTSD treatment program.
All 195 veterans met DSM-IV-TR diagnosis for PTSD. The sample was 53% male with a mean age of 48 years. Self-reported race was 50% White and 45% African American. The Posttraumatic Cognitions Inventory was used to assess trauma-related cognitions. The PTSD Checklist and Beck Depression Inventory-II were used to assess PTSD and depression, respectively. Cross-lagged panel models were used to test the longitudinal associations between trauma-related cognitions, PTSD, and depression. Measures were administered at three time points: pre-, mid-, and posttreatment.
Change in posttraumatic cognitions (self-blame; negative beliefs about the self) preceded change in PTSD. In addition, (a) change in negative beliefs about the self preceded change in depression, (b) change in depression preceded change in self-blame cognitions, and (c) change in depression preceded change in PTSD.
Findings support the hypothesized underlying mechanisms of CPT in showing that change in trauma-related cognitions precedes change in PTSD symptoms. Results suggest that reduction of depression may be important in influencing reduction of PTSD among veterans in residential PTSD treatment.
尽管认知加工疗法(CPT)作为创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的一种治疗方法有强有力的实证支持,但研究尚未直接检验CPT潜在的假设改变机制——即与创伤相关的认知改变会导致PTSD和抑郁症状的改变。为了更好地理解心理治疗改变的潜在机制,本研究调查了在一个为期7周的住院PTSD治疗项目中接受CPT的退伍军人中,与创伤相关的认知、PTSD和抑郁之间的纵向关联。
所有195名退伍军人符合PTSD的DSM-IV-TR诊断标准。样本中53%为男性,平均年龄48岁。自我报告的种族为50%白人,45%非裔美国人。使用创伤后认知量表评估与创伤相关的认知。分别使用PTSD检查表和贝克抑郁量表-II评估PTSD和抑郁。采用交叉滞后面板模型来检验与创伤相关的认知、PTSD和抑郁之间的纵向关联。在三个时间点进行测量:治疗前、治疗中期和治疗后。
创伤后认知(自责;对自我的负面信念)的改变先于PTSD的改变。此外,(a)对自我的负面信念的改变先于抑郁的改变,(b)抑郁的改变先于自责认知的改变,(c)抑郁的改变先于PTSD的改变。
研究结果支持了CPT的假设潜在机制,表明与创伤相关的认知改变先于PTSD症状的改变。结果表明,在住院PTSD治疗中,减轻抑郁可能对影响退伍军人PTSD的减轻很重要。