Friedlander L, McElroy K, Daniel B, Cullinan M, Hanlin S
N Z Dent J. 2015 Jun;111(2):58-64.
This study aimed to investigate treatment protocols and opinions towards direct pulp capping (DPC) amongst New Zealand (NZ) general dental practitioners (GDP) through a Practice Based Research Network (PBRN) study.
Mixed-methods approach using qualitative thematic and quantitative analysis.
An on-line survey containing Likert scale items and open-ended questions was distributed to GDPs on the Dental Council of New Zealand (DCNZ) register (2012) to collect information on practitioner demographics, treatment protocols, continuing professional development (CPD) and philosophies towards DPC. RESULTs: Two hundred and ten GDPs from North and South Islands providing care in main centres and rural areas engaged with the PBRN and participated in the study. Almost all performed DPC treatment although it was not a common procedure. DPC was perceived as 'successful' or 'very successful' by 95% of respondents, mostly for cases of reversible pulpitis. Most provided DPC for patients of all ages but younger patients were perceived to have the best clinical outcomes. Calcium hydroxide and MTA were the most commonly used materials for DPC. MTA was believed to have the best outcome but cost and handling properties were barriers to its use. The majority of respondents had participated in CPD related to vital pulp therapy and regarded this treatment as conservative and providing time and financial benefits compared with more invasive treatment. Clinicians' timeframes for assessing healing were variable, and combined clinical and radiographic findings were considered most useful.
New Zealand dentists perceive DPC as a successful and conservative treatment in selected cases. The findings have provided insights into engagement of NZ dentists in using research to inform everyday clinical practice through a PBRN study.
本研究旨在通过一项基于实践的研究网络(PBRN)研究,调查新西兰普通牙科医生(GDP)对直接盖髓术(DPC)的治疗方案和看法。
采用定性主题分析和定量分析的混合方法。
向新西兰牙科理事会(DCNZ)登记册(2012年)上的GDP发放一份包含李克特量表项目和开放式问题的在线调查问卷,以收集有关从业者人口统计学、治疗方案、继续职业发展(CPD)以及对DPC的理念等信息。
来自北岛和南岛、在主要中心和农村地区提供护理服务的210名GDP参与了该PBRN并参与了研究。几乎所有人都进行DPC治疗,尽管这不是一个常见的程序。95%的受访者认为DPC“成功”或“非常成功”,主要用于可逆性牙髓炎病例。大多数人对所有年龄段的患者都进行DPC,但年轻患者被认为临床效果最佳。氢氧化钙和MTA是DPC最常用的材料。人们认为MTA效果最佳,但成本和操作性能是其使用的障碍。大多数受访者参加过与牙髓活力治疗相关的CPD,并认为这种治疗较为保守,与侵入性更强的治疗相比,能节省时间和费用。临床医生评估愈合的时间框架各不相同,临床和影像学检查结果相结合被认为最有用。
新西兰牙医认为DPC在某些特定病例中是一种成功且保守的治疗方法。这些研究结果通过一项PBRN研究,为新西兰牙医如何利用研究来指导日常临床实践提供了见解。