Department of Orthopaedics, Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI.
Department of Orthopaedics, Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI.
Am J Med. 2015 Nov;128(11):1257-62. doi: 10.1016/j.amjmed.2015.07.022. Epub 2015 Aug 1.
Over the course of the last generation, the cost of medical school attendance and medical student debt has increased drastically. Medical student debt has been reported as high as $350,000, and the Association of American Medical Colleges (AAMC) reports that medical school tuition continues to increase annually. The increasing cost of medical education and associated financial burden is now beginning to deter potential applicants from pursuing a career in medicine. In this study we aimed to assess medical school tuition across the US. We hypothesized that the cost of medical school attendance is variable across all regions of the US, and as a result, the financial burden on medical students is inconsistent.
All 123 allopathic medical schools accredited by the AAMC were assessed in this investigation. In-state and out-of-state tuitions for the year 2016 were obtained from U.S. News and World Report. Additionally, medical school size was collected. Regions were defined according to the US Census Bureau definition, with the US being divided into 4 regions: Northeast, Midwest, South, and West.
There was no difference in average medical school size among the 4 regions (P > .05). Average in-state tuition was $38,291.56 ± $9801.38 (95% confidence interval [CI], $34,658.07-$41,513.46) in the Midwest, $45,923.04 ± $9178.87 (95% CI, $42,566.28-$49,216.78) in the Northeast, $32,287.78 ± $12,277.53 (95% CI, $28,581.90-$35,378.68) in the South, and $37,745.40 ± $11,414.37 (95% CI, $30,063.28-$40,458.99) in the West. In-state tuition in the South was significantly lower than in the Northeast, West, and Midwest (P < .05). In-state tuition in the Northeast was significantly higher than in the South, West, and Midwest (P < .05). Average out-of-state tuition is $54,104.04 ± $8227.65 (95% CI, $51,207.6-$57,000.39) in the Midwest, $53,180.10 ± $3963.71 (95% CI, $51,761.71-$54,598.50) in the Northeast, $48,191.86 ± $12,578.13 (95% CI, $44,595.84-$51,787.89) in the South, and $52,920.47 ± $7400.83 (95% CI, $49,175.13-$56,665.80) in the West. Out-of-state tuition was significantly lower in the South in comparison with the Midwest and Northeast (P < .05), but was not significantly different than the West (P > .05).
Despite no significant difference in medical school size among the 4 regions of the US that were assessed, there is significant regional variation in tuition, with higher tuition in private vs public schools. This study suggests that medical schools place a variable financial burden on the medical students based on region. The ongoing increases in medical school tuition are unsustainable, as future trainees will face substantial financial stress as they attempt to pay off their debt while initiating medical practice after residency and fellowship training.
在上一代人的时间里,医学院的学费和医学生债务急剧增加。据报道,医学生债务高达 35 万美元,美国医学协会(AAMC)报告称,医学院的学费仍在逐年上涨。不断增加的医学教育成本和相关经济负担现在开始阻止潜在的申请人从事医学职业。在这项研究中,我们旨在评估美国的医学院学费。我们假设,在美国的所有地区,医学院的学费都是不同的,因此,医学生的经济负担也是不一致的。
这项研究评估了美国所有 123 所获得 AAMC 认证的医科学校。2016 年的州内和州外学费均来自《美国新闻与世界报道》。此外,还收集了医学院的规模。根据美国人口普查局的定义,将地区分为四个:东北部、中西部、南部和西部。
四个地区的医学院平均规模没有差异(P >.05)。州内学费在中西部为$38,291.56±$9801.38(95%置信区间,$34,658.07-$41,513.46),在东北部为$45,923.04±$9178.87(95%置信区间,$42,566.28-$49,216.78),在南部为$32,287.78±$12,277.53(95%置信区间,$28,581.90-$35,378.68),在西部为$37,745.40±$11,414.37(95%置信区间,$30,063.28-$40,458.99)。南部的州内学费明显低于东北部、西部和中西部(P <.05)。东北部的州内学费明显高于南部、西部和中西部(P <.05)。州外学费在中西部为$54,104.04±$8227.65(95%置信区间,$51,207.6-$57,000.39),在东北部为$53,180.10±$3963.71(95%置信区间,$51,761.71-$54,598.50),在南部为$48,191.86±$12,578.13(95%置信区间,$44,595.84-$51,787.89),在西部为$52,920.47±$7400.83(95%置信区间,$49,175.13-$56,665.80)。与中西部和东北部相比,南部的州外学费明显较低(P <.05),但与西部没有显著差异(P >.05)。
尽管评估的美国四个地区的医学院规模没有显著差异,但学费存在显著的地区差异,私立学校比公立学校的学费更高。本研究表明,医学院根据地区向医学生施加了不同的经济负担。医学院学费的持续上涨是不可持续的,因为未来的受训者在完成住院医师和专科医师培训后开始行医时,将面临巨大的经济压力,需要偿还债务。