Jin Guanghui, Zhao Yali, Chen Chao, Wang Wenji, Du Juan, Lu Xiaoqin
Department of General Practice, School of General Practice and Continuing Education, Capital Medical University, Beijing, P. R. China.
Puren Hospital, Beijing, P. R. China.
PLoS One. 2015 Aug 10;10(8):e0135121. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0135121. eCollection 2015.
Community health service center (CHSC) and community health service station (CHSS) are the main institutions where general practitioners (GPs) deliver primary care in the urban area of China. Motivated by incentive policies, visits to community health service institutions (CHSIs) increased gradually in recent years, but concerns had been raised on the quality of general practice consultation. This is a preliminary study aimed to investigate the existing problems of general practice consultation in Beijing and provide practical evidence for developing relevant policies.
Six GPs from 2 CHSCs and 3 CHSSs were selected by purposive sampling. The GPs were observed for 4 or 5 consecutive days during January 2013 to March 2013. The length and content of consultations were recorded in structured observation forms. Quantitative description was applied to describe the median, percentage and frequency of variables.
A total of 1135 consultations were observed. The most frequent reason for consultations was specific prescription (61.6%), followed by presenting symptoms (20.7%), check-up (9.1%), counseling (5.4%), transfusion & injection (3.0%) and sickness certificate (0.2%). The median consultation length of all consultations was 2.0 minutes. The GPs prescribed in 81.0% of the consultations, on the other hand, history taking, physical examination, explanation of illness and health education only took place in 27.0%, 28.0%, 21.9% and 17.7% of the consultations respectively.
The adequacy of consultation length in CHSIs is in doubt. Most patients visited the CHSIs for prescription renewal. Health promotion e.g. health education are not adequately provided in consultations. The quality of general practice consultations was jeopardized by the large amount of patient flow for medicine renewal. Policies should be adjusted to reduce unnecessary consultations. Further studies are in need to evaluate the outcome and influencing factors of general practice consultation in China.
社区卫生服务中心(CHSC)和社区卫生服务站(CHSS)是中国城市地区全科医生提供初级医疗服务的主要机构。受激励政策推动,近年来社区卫生服务机构(CHSI)的就诊量逐渐增加,但人们对全科医疗咨询的质量提出了担忧。这是一项初步研究,旨在调查北京全科医疗咨询中存在的问题,并为制定相关政策提供实际依据。
通过目的抽样法从2个社区卫生服务中心和3个社区卫生服务站选取6名全科医生。在2013年1月至2013年3月期间,对这些全科医生进行连续4或5天的观察。咨询的时长和内容记录在结构化观察表格中。采用定量描述来描述变量的中位数、百分比和频率。
共观察了1135次咨询。最常见的咨询原因是特定处方(61.6%),其次是出现症状(20.7%)、检查(9.1%)、咨询(5.4%)、输血及注射(3.0%)和病假证明(0.2%)。所有咨询的中位时长为2.0分钟。另一方面,81.0%的咨询中医生开了处方,而问诊、体格检查、病情解释和健康教育分别仅在27.0%、28.0%、21.9%和17.7%的咨询中出现。
社区卫生服务机构咨询时长是否充足存在疑问。大多数患者前往社区卫生服务机构是为了续开处方。在咨询中未充分提供如健康教育等健康促进服务。大量患者为续药而来导致全科医疗咨询质量受到损害。应调整政策以减少不必要的咨询。需要进一步研究来评估中国全科医疗咨询的结果及影响因素。