Katzenbach Julia E, Foy Daniel S
From Wheat Ridge Animal Hospital, 3695 Kipling Street, Wheat Ridge, CO 8003.
J Vet Emerg Crit Care (San Antonio). 2015 Sep-Oct;25(5):655-9. doi: 10.1111/vec.12349. Epub 2015 Aug 10.
To compare the effect of antivenom administration on mortality, hospitalization duration, and cost of hospitalization for dogs envenomated by Crotalus viridis.
Retrospective study (January 2004-December 2012).
Private veterinary emergency and referral center.
One hundred thirteen dogs with confirmed C. viridis envenomation.
None.
Dogs were divided into groups treated with either supportive care only (group 1) or supportive care plus antivenin crotalidae polyvalent (group 2). A modified snakebite severity score was used to compare patients from group 1 and group 2. Patients in group 2 received one 10 mL vial of antivenin crotalidae polyvalent over 4-6 hours. The mortality rate was 1.8% (2/113). Group 1 had a median duration of hospitalization of 20 hours (range, 8-50 hours), while group 2 had a median duration of hospitalization of 24 hours (range, 1.5-74 hours). Group 1 had a median cost of hospitalization of 1050.00 USD (range, 423.52-2266.09 USD) while group 2 had a median cost of hospitalization of 2002.19 USD (range, 1139.91-6908.01 USD). Both the duration of hospitalization (P < 0.01) and the cost of hospitalization (P < 0.01) were significantly greater in the group of dogs receiving antivenom.
Both the cost and the duration of hospitalization were significantly greater in the group of dogs that received antivenom. The difference in cost between the groups was approximately the cost of the antivenom vial and administration. Amongst the parameters evaluated, no significant benefit was associated with antivenom administered to dogs envenomated by C. viridis.
比较抗蛇毒血清给药对被绿曼巴蛇咬伤的犬的死亡率、住院时间和住院费用的影响。
回顾性研究(2004年1月至2012年12月)。
私立兽医急诊和转诊中心。
113只确诊被绿曼巴蛇咬伤的犬。
无。
将犬分为仅接受支持性治疗的组(第1组)和接受支持性治疗加多价抗响尾蛇毒血清的组(第2组)。使用改良的蛇咬伤严重程度评分来比较第1组和第2组的患者。第2组的患者在4至6小时内接受1瓶10 mL的多价抗响尾蛇毒血清。死亡率为1.8%(2/113)。第1组的住院时间中位数为20小时(范围为8至50小时),而第2组的住院时间中位数为24小时(范围为1.5至74小时)。第1组的住院费用中位数为1050.00美元(范围为423.52至2266.09美元),而第2组的住院费用中位数为2002.19美元(范围为1139.91至6908.01美元)。接受抗蛇毒血清的犬组的住院时间(P < 0.01)和住院费用(P < 0.01)均显著更高。
接受抗蛇毒血清的犬组的住院费用和住院时间均显著更高。两组之间的费用差异约为抗蛇毒血清瓶和给药的费用。在所评估的参数中,给被绿曼巴蛇咬伤的犬使用抗蛇毒血清未带来显著益处。