DiDiodato Giulio, McArthur Leslie, Beyene Joseph, Smieja Marek, Thabane Lehana
Department of Critical Care Medicine, Royal Victoria Regional Health Centre, Barrie, Ontario, L4M 6M2, Canada.
Pharmacy, Royal Victoria Regional Health Centre, Barrie, Ontario, L4M 6M2, Canada.
Trials. 2015 Aug 14;16:355. doi: 10.1186/s13063-015-0871-2.
Pneumonia is responsible for a large proportion of hospital admissions and antibiotic utilization. Physician adherence to evidence-based pneumonia management guidelines is poor. Antimicrobial stewardship programs (ASPs) are an effective intervention to mitigate against unwarranted variation from these guidelines. Despite this benefit, ASPs have not been shown to reduce the length of stay of hospitalized patients with pneumonia. In immune-competent adult patients admitted to a hospital ward with a diagnosis of community-acquired pneumonia, does a multi-faceted ASP utilizing prospective chart audit and feedback reduce the length of stay, compared with usual care, without increasing the risk of death or readmission 30 days after discharge from hospital?
METHODS/DESIGN: Starting on 1 April 2013, all consecutive immune-competent adult patients (>18 years old) admitted to a hospital ward with a positive febrile respiratory illness screening questionnaire and a diagnosis of pneumonia by the attending physician will be eligible for inclusion in this non-randomized study. All eligible patients who fulfill the ASP review criteria will undergo a prospective chart audit, followed by an ASP recommendation provided to the attending physician. The attending physician is responsible for implementing or rejecting the ASP recommendation. This is a modified stepped-wedge design with a baseline data collection period of 3 months, followed by non-random sequential introduction of the ASP intervention on each of four hospital wards in a single community-based, academic-affiliated 339-bed acute-care hospital in Barrie, ON, Canada. The primary outcome measure is hospital length of stay; secondary outcome measures include days and duration of antibiotic therapy, and inadvertent adverse outcomes of 30 day post-discharge mortality and hospital readmission rates. Differences in outcome measures will be assessed using extended Cox regression analysis. Time to ASP intervention is included as a time-dependent covariate in the final model, to account for time-dependent bias.
By designing a pragmatic clinical trial with unique design and analytic features, we not only expect to demonstrate the effectiveness of a real-world ASP, but also provide a model for program evaluation that can be used more broadly to improve patient safety and quality of care.
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02264756 .
肺炎导致大量患者住院及使用抗生素。医生对循证肺炎管理指南的依从性较差。抗菌药物管理计划(ASPs)是一种有效干预措施,可减少与这些指南的不必要差异。尽管有此益处,但ASP尚未显示能缩短肺炎住院患者的住院时间。在诊断为社区获得性肺炎并入住医院病房的免疫功能正常成年患者中,与常规治疗相比,采用前瞻性病历审核和反馈的多方面ASP是否能在不增加出院30天后死亡或再入院风险的情况下缩短住院时间?
方法/设计:从2013年4月1日起,所有连续入住医院病房、发热呼吸道疾病筛查问卷呈阳性且经主治医生诊断为肺炎的免疫功能正常成年患者(>18岁)均符合纳入本非随机研究的条件。所有符合ASP审核标准的合格患者将接受前瞻性病历审核,随后向主治医生提供ASP建议。主治医生负责实施或拒绝ASP建议。这是一种改良的阶梯楔形设计,基线数据收集期为3个月,随后在加拿大安大略省巴里市一家拥有339张床位的社区学术附属急性护理医院的四个医院病房中,对ASP干预措施进行非随机顺序引入。主要结局指标是住院时间;次要结局指标包括抗生素治疗的天数和持续时间,以及出院后30天的意外不良结局,即死亡率和医院再入院率。结局指标的差异将使用扩展Cox回归分析进行评估。ASP干预时间作为时间依赖性协变量纳入最终模型,以考虑时间依赖性偏倚。
通过设计一项具有独特设计和分析特征的实用临床试验,我们不仅期望证明现实世界中ASP的有效性,还提供一个项目评估模型,可更广泛地用于提高患者安全性和护理质量。
ClinicalTrials.gov NCT02264756 。