Kasch Cindy, Haimerl Peggy, Heuwieser Wolfgang, Arlt Sebastian
J Vet Med Educ. 2015 Winter;42(4):340-5. doi: 10.3138/jvme.0415-053R. Epub 2015 Aug 28.
Rather than merely transferring information, veterinary education should stimulate and motivate students and encourage them to think. Currently in veterinary education, most curricula use the method of frontal teaching (e.g., in lectures). A student-centered critical approach to information is rarely used. Our research sought to determine if students consider in-course discussion useful and if sufficient possibilities for discussion are provided and supported by their lecturers. In December 2013, we conducted a survey of fourth-year students. Specifically, we wanted to know if students consider in-course discussion about course content useful for successful learning and if students wish to have more opportunities for discussion during class time. Finally, we wanted to identify barriers that limit the students' motivation and ability to engage in discussion of course content. In total, 105 students completed the survey. The majority of students agreed or strongly agreed that clinical topics should be discussed during class time. Frequently stated reasons were improved learning (85.7%) and the opportunity to look at topics from different perspectives (92.4%). In conclusion, we found a considerable dearth of and request for discussion within veterinary education. In light of these findings, we emphasize the need for new teaching strategies that promote independent thinking and critical questioning. We suggest the implementation of more discussion opportunities in well considered and moderated settings in veterinary teaching.
兽医教育不应仅仅是传递信息,而应激发和激励学生并鼓励他们思考。目前在兽医教育中,大多数课程采用的是正面教学法(如讲座)。以学生为中心的批判性信息处理方法很少被使用。我们的研究旨在确定学生是否认为课程中的讨论有用,以及他们的讲师是否提供并支持了足够的讨论机会。2013年12月,我们对四年级学生进行了一项调查。具体而言,我们想知道学生是否认为关于课程内容的课堂讨论对成功学习有用,以及学生是否希望在课堂上有更多的讨论机会。最后,我们想找出限制学生参与课程内容讨论的动机和能力的障碍。共有105名学生完成了调查。大多数学生同意或强烈同意临床主题应在课堂上进行讨论。常见的理由是学习效果提高(85.7%)和有机会从不同角度看待主题(92.4%)。总之,我们发现兽医教育中讨论的机会相当匮乏,且学生对此有需求。鉴于这些发现,我们强调需要新的教学策略来促进独立思考和批判性提问。我们建议在经过充分考虑和适度安排的兽医教学环境中增加更多的讨论机会。