Schölvinck D W, Bergman J J G H M, Visser M, Weusten B L A M
Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, St Antonius Hospital, Nieuwegein, The Netherlands.
Department of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, Academic Medical Center, Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
Dis Esophagus. 2016 Aug;29(6):528-36. doi: 10.1111/dote.12379. Epub 2015 Aug 28.
In the treatment of early esophageal Barrett's neoplasia, radiofrequency ablation may be hindered by stenosis due to prior endoscopic resection (ER). The flexible balloon-based circumferential CryoBalloon Ablation System (CBAS) may overcome this problem by the conformability of the compliant balloon which might enable circumferential cryoablation in a stenosis. The aim of the current study was to evaluate the feasibility of the CBAS as well as the dose-response effect of cryoablation in a strictured esophagus model. In six pigs, a stenosis was induced by ER (3 cm in length, 75% of circumference) in the proximal, mid, and distal esophagus. After 28 days, cryoablation with the CBAS was performed, with the length of ablation time (6, 8, or 10 seconds) randomly assigned per stricture location within the esophagus. Four days post-ablation, the esophagi were harvested for histopathological assessment of the percentage of the total circumference affected by cryoablation and the maximum depth of necrosis. At 28 days, all 18 ER areas had transformed into strictures with ±50% of its original diameter remaining. In 9 of 18 strictures, more than one attempt for cryoablation was necessary due to displacement of the balloon. Histopathological evaluation showed a wide range in circumferential uniformity (0-100%) and maximum necrosis depth (epithelium to external proper muscle layer) of cryoablation, both independent of ablation times. Deepest ablation effects were seen at the center of the resection-induced scar. This first generation CryoBalloon Focal Ablation System was not feasible for ablation within severe stenoses, since it results in inconsistent circumferential uniformity of cryoablation with subsequent differences in depth of ablation. Further research with a next generation CBAS in a more realistic stricture model is warranted.
在早期食管巴雷特肿瘤的治疗中,射频消融可能会因先前的内镜切除术(ER)导致的狭窄而受到阻碍。基于柔性球囊的圆周冷冻球囊消融系统(CBAS)可能通过顺应性球囊的贴合性克服这一问题,这或许能在狭窄部位进行圆周冷冻消融。本研究的目的是评估CBAS在狭窄食管模型中的可行性以及冷冻消融的剂量反应效应。在6头猪的食管近端、中段和远端,通过ER诱导出长度为3厘米、周长75%的狭窄。28天后,使用CBAS进行冷冻消融,每个食管狭窄部位的消融时间(6、8或10秒)随机分配。消融后4天,取出食管进行组织病理学评估,以确定受冷冻消融影响的总周长百分比和最大坏死深度。28天时,所有18个ER区域均已转变为狭窄,剩余直径为原始直径的±50%。在18个狭窄中有9个,由于球囊移位,需要进行不止一次的冷冻消融尝试。组织病理学评估显示,冷冻消融的圆周均匀性(0 - 100%)和最大坏死深度(从上皮到外固有肌层)范围广泛,且均与消融时间无关。在切除诱导的瘢痕中心观察到最深的消融效果。第一代冷冻球囊聚焦消融系统在严重狭窄内进行消融不可行,因为它导致冷冻消融的圆周均匀性不一致,进而导致消融深度存在差异。有必要在更现实的狭窄模型中对下一代CBAS进行进一步研究。