Manning Catherine, Neil Louise, Karaminis Themelis, Pellicano Elizabeth
J Vis. 2015 Aug 1;15(11):17. doi: 10.1167/15.11.17.
Adult observers show elevated speed discrimination thresholds when comparing the speeds of objects moving across a boundary compared to those moving parallel to a boundary (Verghese & McKee, 2006)-an effect that has been attributed to grouping processes in conjunction with a prior for smooth motion. Here, we extended Verghese and McKee's (2006) paradigm to typically developing children (n = 35) and children with autism (n = 26) and compared their performance with that of typical adults (n = 19). Speed discrimination thresholds were measured in three conditions: (a) with dots moving parallel to a boundary, (b) with dots moving perpendicular to a boundary, and (c) with dots in each stimulus half moving in orthogonal, oblique directions. As expected, participants had higher speed discrimination thresholds when dots appeared to cross a boundary compared to when dots moved parallel to the boundary. However, participants had even higher thresholds when dots moved in oblique, orthogonal directions, where grouping should be minimal. All groups of participants showed a similar pattern of performance across conditions although children had higher thresholds than adult participants overall. We consider various explanations for the pattern of performance obtained, including enhanced sensitivity for shearing motions and reduced sensitivity for discriminating different directions. Our results demonstrate that the speed discrimination judgments of typically developing children and children with autism are similarly affected by spatial configuration as those of typical adults and provide further evidence that speed discrimination is unimpaired in children with autism.
与平行于边界移动的物体速度相比,成年观察者在比较跨越边界移动的物体速度时,表现出更高的速度辨别阈值(Verghese & McKee,2006)——这种效应被归因于分组过程与平滑运动先验的结合。在此,我们将Verghese和McKee(2006)的范式扩展到了发育正常的儿童(n = 35)和自闭症儿童(n = 26),并将他们的表现与典型成年人(n = 19)的表现进行了比较。在三种条件下测量了速度辨别阈值:(a)点平行于边界移动,(b)点垂直于边界移动,以及(c)每个刺激中的点在正交、倾斜方向上移动。正如预期的那样,与点平行于边界移动时相比,当点似乎跨越边界时,参与者具有更高的速度辨别阈值。然而,当点在倾斜、正交方向上移动时,参与者的阈值甚至更高,在这种情况下分组应该是最小的。所有参与者组在不同条件下都表现出类似的表现模式,尽管总体而言儿童的阈值高于成年参与者。我们考虑了对所获得的表现模式的各种解释,包括对剪切运动的敏感性增强和对辨别不同方向的敏感性降低。我们的结果表明,发育正常的儿童和自闭症儿童的速度辨别判断与典型成年人的速度辨别判断同样受到空间配置的影响,并进一步证明自闭症儿童的速度辨别没有受损。