Gugger Y, Mühldorfer M, Prommersberger K-J, van Schoonhoven J
Klinik für Handchirurgie, Rhön-Klinikum, Bad Neustadt a.d. Saale.
Handchir Mikrochir Plast Chir. 2015 Oct;47(5):297-303. doi: 10.1055/s-0035-1559721. Epub 2015 Sep 7.
Stabilization of the distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) with reconstruction of distal radioulnar ligaments as outlined by Adams is indicated if a refixation of the triangular fibrocartilage complex (TFCC) is no longer possible. There is little information given on the results of these procedures in literature.
The purpose of this retrospective study was to analyze with use of objective and subjective criteria, whether the reconstruction of the radioulnar ligaments according to Adams allows a sufficient re-stabilization of the DRUJ.
14 patients (9 female, 5 male) with a mean age of 29 (24-62) years underwent an Adams' procedure between 2004 to 2011. After an average follow up of 67 (26-110) months 11 patients could be examined retrospectively regarding functional results and subjective self assessment. As objective parameters assessment of distal radioulnar joint stability, range of forearm rotation and grip strength were measured. Krimmer- and Mayo Wrist Score were evaluated. Subjective parameters as DASH-score, patient's self assessment and pain (verbal and visual analogue scale) were recorded.
In 5 patients the DRUJ was stable, in 2 it was lax. According the 4 patients with ongoing instability, one patient reported on improvement, 2 on unchanged instability and one an impaired sensation of instability. In 2 patients clicking during forearm rotation could be provoked. 2 patients suffered from restricted forearm rotation with loss of range of motion of 60 and 70° respectively. Pronation-supination averaged 89% of the opposite side and 99% compared to preoperative. Grip strength averaged 69% of the opposite side. Krimmer-Score was 74, Mayo Wrist-Score 73, and DASH-Score 24 points. Pain at rest on visual analogue scale (0-10) was 3 and 5 with activity. 6 patients had improved, 2 declined and 3 unchanged pain. Patient´s satisfaction rated 0-10 was 8. Eight would undergo again same operation procedure.
The clinical findings show, that reconstruction of distal radioulnar ligaments according to Adams in patients with DRUJ instability and no repairable parts of TFCC, do not allow to re-stabilize the DRUJ in all patients. There is a need for further investigations trying to re-stabilize the DRUJ.
如果三角纤维软骨复合体(TFCC)无法再进行修复,可按照亚当斯所述方法通过重建桡尺远侧韧带(DRUJ)来实现其稳定。但文献中关于这些手术结果的信息较少。
本回顾性研究旨在通过客观和主观标准分析,按照亚当斯方法重建桡尺韧带是否能使DRUJ充分重新稳定。
2004年至2011年间,14例患者(9例女性,5例男性)平均年龄29岁(24 - 62岁)接受了亚当斯手术。平均随访67个月(26 - 110个月)后,对11例患者的功能结果和主观自我评估进行了回顾性检查。测量了桡尺远侧关节稳定性、前臂旋转范围和握力等客观参数。评估了克里默和梅奥腕关节评分。记录了DASH评分、患者自我评估和疼痛(语言和视觉模拟量表)等主观参数。
5例患者的DRUJ稳定,2例松弛。在4例仍存在不稳定的患者中,1例报告有所改善,2例不稳定情况未变,1例不稳定感觉受损。2例患者在前臂旋转时可诱发弹响。2例患者前臂旋转受限,活动范围分别丧失60°和70°。旋前 - 旋后平均为对侧的89%,与术前相比为99%。握力平均为对侧的69%。克里默评分74分,梅奥腕关节评分73分,DASH评分为24分。视觉模拟量表(0 - 10)上静息时疼痛为3分,活动时为5分。6例患者疼痛改善,2例恶化,3例不变。患者满意度(0 - 10分)为8分。8例患者愿意再次接受相同手术。
临床结果表明,对于DRUJ不稳定且TFCC不可修复部分的患者,按照亚当斯方法重建桡尺远侧韧带并不能使所有患者重新稳定DRUJ。需要进一步研究以尝试重新稳定DRUJ。