Pouwels J Loes, Lansu Tessa A M, Cillessen Antonius H N
Behavioural Science Institute, Radboud University, Nijmegen, the Netherlands.
Aggress Behav. 2016 May-Jun;42(3):239-53. doi: 10.1002/ab.21614. Epub 2015 Sep 9.
This study had three goals. First, we examined the prevalence of the participant roles of bullying in middle adolescence and possible gender differences therein. Second, we examined the behavioral and status characteristics associated with the participant roles in middle adolescence. Third, we compared two sets of criteria for assigning students to the participant roles of bullying. Participants were 1,638 adolescents (50.9% boys, M(age) = 16.38 years, SD =.80) who completed the shortened participant role questionnaire and peer nominations for peer status and behavioral characteristics. Adolescents were assigned to the participant roles according to the relative criteria of Salmivalli, Lagerspetz, Björkqvist, Österman, and Kaukiainen (1996). Next, the students in each role were divided in two subgroups based on an additional absolute criterion: the Relative Only Criterion subgroup (nominated by less than 10% of their classmates) and the Absolute & Relative Criterion subgroup (nominated by at least 10% of their classmates). Adolescents who bullied or reinforced or assisted bullies were highly popular and disliked and scored high on peer-valued characteristics. Adolescents who were victimized held the weakest social position in the peer group. Adolescents who defended victims were liked and prosocial, but average in popularity and peer-valued characteristics. Outsiders held a socially weak position in the peer group, but were less disliked, less aggressive, and more prosocial than victims. The behavior and status profiles of adolescents in the participant roles were more extreme for the Absolute & Relative Criterion subgroup than for the Relative Only Criterion subgroup.
本研究有三个目标。第一,我们考察了青少年中期欺凌参与者角色的普遍性以及其中可能存在的性别差异。第二,我们考察了与青少年中期参与者角色相关的行为和地位特征。第三,我们比较了将学生分配到欺凌参与者角色的两套标准。研究参与者为1638名青少年(50.9%为男孩,年龄均值M = 16.38岁,标准差SD = 0.80),他们完成了简化版的参与者角色问卷以及关于同伴地位和行为特征的同伴提名。青少年根据萨尔米瓦利、拉格斯佩茨、比约克维斯特、奥斯特曼和考基艾宁(1996年)的相对标准被分配到参与者角色。接下来,根据一个额外的绝对标准,将每个角色中的学生分为两个亚组:仅相对标准亚组(被少于10%的同学提名)和绝对与相对标准亚组(被至少10%的同学提名)。实施欺凌、强化或协助欺凌的青少年非常受欢迎且遭人厌恶,在同伴重视的特征方面得分很高。受欺凌的青少年在同伴群体中社会地位最薄弱。为受害者辩护的青少年受人喜欢且具有亲社会行为,但在受欢迎程度和同伴重视的特征方面处于中等水平。局外人在同伴群体中社会地位较弱,但比起受害者,他们不那么遭人厌恶,攻击性较弱,且更具亲社会行为。对于绝对与相对标准亚组,处于参与者角色的青少年的行为和地位概况比仅相对标准亚组更为极端。