Greenberg Nili, Carel Rafael, Portnov Boris A
Isr Med Assoc J. 2015 Jul;17(7):445-50.
Studies of the respiratory effects of air pollution in Israel published in peer-reviewed journals have been infrequent. Most empiric evidence relates to the association between air pollution and childhood asthma; other air pollution effects on other illnesses are less thoroughly studied. Our evaluation provides a possible explanation for the quite contradictory results demonstrated in the various studies. Actual effect estimates appear to differ considerably, ranging from no air pollution effect to a reasonably strong association detected between PM10 and asthma. We attribute these discrepancies to different research methodologies and different types of data used in various studies.
发表在同行评审期刊上的关于以色列空气污染对呼吸系统影响的研究并不常见。大多数实证证据都与空气污染和儿童哮喘之间的关联有关;空气污染对其他疾病的影响则研究得不够充分。我们的评估为各项研究中呈现出的相当矛盾的结果提供了一种可能的解释。实际的效应估计似乎差异很大,从没有空气污染效应到发现PM10与哮喘之间存在相当强的关联不等。我们将这些差异归因于不同的研究方法以及各项研究中使用的不同类型的数据。