Dal Martello Maria F, DeBruine Lisa M, Maloney Laurence T
J Vis. 2015;15(13):5. doi: 10.1167/15.13.5.
Typical judgments involving faces are disrupted by inversion, with the Thatcher illusion serving as a compelling example. In two experiments, we examined how inversion affects allocentric kin recognition-the ability to judge the degree of genetic relatedness of others. In the first experiment, participants judged whether pairs of photographs of children portrayed siblings or unrelated children. Half of the pairs were siblings, half were unrelated. In three experimental conditions, photographs were viewed in upright orientation, flipped around a horizontal axis, or rotated 180°. Neither rotation nor flipping had any detectable effect on allocentric kin recognition. In the second experiment, participants judged pairs of photographs of adult women. Half of the pairs were sisters, half were unrelated. We again found no significant effect of facial inversion. Unlike almost all other face judgments, judgments of kinship from facial appearance do not rely on perceptual cues disrupted by inversion, suggesting that they rely more on spatially localized cues rather than "holistic" cues. We conclude that kin recognition is not simply a byproduct of other face perception abilities. We discuss the implications for cue combination models of other facial judgments that are affected by inversion.
涉及面孔的典型判断会因倒置而受到干扰,撒切尔错觉就是一个有说服力的例子。在两项实验中,我们研究了倒置如何影响以他人为中心的亲属识别——即判断他人基因关联程度的能力。在第一个实验中,参与者判断成对的儿童照片描绘的是兄弟姐妹还是非亲属儿童。其中一半的对子是兄弟姐妹,另一半是非亲属。在三种实验条件下,照片以直立方向、绕水平轴翻转或旋转180°的方式呈现。旋转和翻转都对以他人为中心的亲属识别没有任何可检测到的影响。在第二个实验中,参与者判断成对的成年女性照片。其中一半的对子是姐妹,另一半是非亲属。我们再次发现面部倒置没有显著影响。与几乎所有其他面孔判断不同,基于面部外观的亲属关系判断并不依赖于因倒置而被破坏的感知线索,这表明它们更多地依赖于空间局部线索而非“整体”线索。我们得出结论,亲属识别并非简单地是其他面孔感知能力的副产品。我们讨论了倒置对其他受影响的面部判断的线索组合模型的影响。