Dubé Timothy V, Schinke Robert J, Strasser Roger, Couper Ian, Lightfoot Nancy E
Northern Ontario School of Medicine, Sudbury and Thunder Bay, Ontario, Canada.
School of Human Kinetics, Laurentian University, Sudbury, Ontario, Canada.
Med Educ. 2015 Oct;49(10):1028-37. doi: 10.1111/medu.12797.
This paper describes the transition processes experienced by Year 3 medical students during their longitudinal integrated clerkship (LIC). The authors conceptualise the stages that encompass the transition through a LIC.
The purpose of this study was to understand the perspectives of 12 Northern Ontario School of Medicine (NOSM) Year 3 medical students about their transition process.
Data were collected longitudinally through three conversational interviews with each of these students, occurring before, during and after the clerkship. The authors used a guided walk methodology to explore students' everyday lives and elicit insights about the transition process, prompted by the locations and clinical settings in which the clerkship occurred.
Participants identified three interconnected stages in the transition process: (i) shifting from classroom to clinical learning; (ii) dealing with disorientation and restoring balance, and (iii) seeing oneself as a physician. Interview data provided evidence for the adaptive strategies the participants developed in response to these stages.
Based on these findings, the transition process during a LIC can be characterised as one of entering the unfamiliar, with few forewarnings about the changes, of experiencing moments of confusion and burnout, and of eventual gains in confidence and competence in the clinical roles of a physician. Recommendations are made regarding future research opportunities to further scholarship on transitions.
本文描述了三年级医学生在其纵向整合实习(LIC)期间所经历的过渡过程。作者对涵盖通过LIC进行过渡的各个阶段进行了概念化。
本研究的目的是了解12名安大略省北部医学院(NOSM)三年级医学生对其过渡过程的看法。
通过对每位学生进行三次对话访谈纵向收集数据,访谈分别在实习前、实习期间和实习后进行。作者采用引导式走访方法,根据实习发生的地点和临床环境,探索学生的日常生活并引出有关过渡过程的见解。
参与者确定了过渡过程中的三个相互关联的阶段:(i)从课堂学习转向临床学习;(ii)应对迷失方向并恢复平衡,以及(iii)将自己视为一名医生。访谈数据为参与者针对这些阶段制定的适应性策略提供了证据。
基于这些发现,LIC期间的过渡过程可被描述为进入一个陌生领域的过程,对变化几乎没有预先警告,会经历困惑和倦怠的时刻,最终在医生的临床角色中获得信心和能力。针对未来的研究机会提出了建议,以进一步推动关于过渡的学术研究。