Scherr Courtney L, Christie Juliette, Vadaparampil Susan T
Northwestern University, Chicago, Ill., USA.
Public Health Genomics. 2016;19(1):1-10. doi: 10.1159/000439162. Epub 2015 Sep 22.
Previous studies found genetic counseling increased participants' knowledge about hereditary breast and ovarian cancer (HBOC). However, most explored knowledge gain in unaffected women and the scale most commonly used does not include items that may be more pertinent to breast cancer (BC) survivors.
To explore whether genetic counseling impacts BC survivors' knowledge about HBOC and BC survivor-specific information.
The National Center for Human Genome Research Knowledge Scale and 5 additional items specific to BC survivors were tested among BC survivors; before genetic counseling (time 1), 2-3 weeks after genetic counseling (time 2), and 6 months following genetic counseling (time 3).
A statistically significant change in knowledge over time was found. Post hoc analyses revealed statistically significant increases in knowledge between time 1 (median = 7.00) and time 2 (median = 10.00; p < 0.005), and between time 1 and time 3 (median = 9.00; p < 0.005).
Knowledge increased following genetic counseling, but the highest total average score at any time was <70% out of 100%. Additional analyses revealed items with low rates of correct response at all three time points, raising several concerns and the consideration of alternative approaches to measuring knowledge.
先前的研究发现,遗传咨询可增加参与者对遗传性乳腺癌和卵巢癌(HBOC)的了解。然而,大多数研究探讨的是未受影响女性的知识获取情况,且最常用的量表未纳入可能与乳腺癌(BC)幸存者更相关的项目。
探讨遗传咨询是否会影响BC幸存者对HBOC的了解以及BC幸存者特有的信息。
在BC幸存者中测试了国家人类基因组研究中心知识量表以及另外5个针对BC幸存者的项目;在遗传咨询前(时间1)、遗传咨询后2 - 3周(时间2)以及遗传咨询后6个月(时间3)进行测试。
发现知识水平随时间有统计学上的显著变化。事后分析显示,时间1(中位数 = 7.00)和时间2(中位数 = 10.00;p < 0.005)之间以及时间1和时间3(中位数 = 9.00;p < 0.005)之间的知识有统计学上的显著增加。
遗传咨询后知识有所增加,但任何时候的最高总平均分在满分100%中都低于70%。进一步分析显示,所有三个时间点正确回答率较低的项目,引发了一些担忧,并促使人们考虑采用其他方法来衡量知识。