Wang John J, Title Lawrence M, Martin Thomas N, Wagner Galen S, Warren James W, Horáček B Milan, Sapp John L
Philips Healthcare, Andover, MA, USA.
Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS, Canada.
J Electrocardiol. 2015 Nov-Dec;48(6):1032-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jelectrocard.2015.08.033. Epub 2015 Aug 21.
Existing criteria recommended by ACC/ESC for identifying patients with ST elevation myocardial infarction (STEMI) from the 12-lead ECG perform with high specificity (SP), but low sensitivity (SE). In our previous studies, we found that the SE of ischemia detection can be markedly improved without any loss of SP by calculating, from the 12-lead ECG, ST deviation in 3 "optimal" vessel-specific leads (VSLs). Our original VSLs, based on ΔST body-surface potential maps (BSPMs), have been modified by using the more appropriate J-point BSPMs at peak ischemia (without subtraction of pre-occlusion distributions). The aim of the present study was to compare the performance of these new VSLs with that achieved by the STEMI criteria used in current practice.
Two independent datasets of 12-lead ECGs were used: the STAFF III dataset acquired during ischemic episodes caused by balloon inflation in LAD (n=35), RCA (n=47), and LCx (n=17) coronary arteries, and the Glasgow dataset comprising admission 12-lead ECGs of 116 patients who were hospitalized for chest pain and underwent contrast-enhanced cardiac MRI that confirmed AMI in 58 patients (50%).
We found that, in the STAFF III dataset, the detection of ischemic state by the STEMI criteria attained SE/SP of 60/97%, whereas SE/SP values of VSLs were 72/98%. In the Glasgow dataset, STEMI criteria yielded SE/SP of 43/98%, whereas the VSLs improved SE/SP to 60/98%. The most significant increase in diagnostic performance appeared in patients with LCx coronary artery occlusion: in STAFF III data (n=17) SE achieved by STEMI criteria was improved by the VSLs from 35% to 71%; in Glasgow data (n=12) SE of 31% achieved by STEMI criteria was improved by the VSLs to 69%.
In our study population, existing ACC/ESC STEMI criteria complemented by the new VSLs yielded much improved sensitivity of ischemia detection without any detrimental effect on specificity. This finding needs to be corroborated on a larger chest-pain patient population with typical prevalence of acute ischemia presented to the emergency rooms.
美国心脏病学会(ACC)/美国心脏协会(ESC)推荐的用于从12导联心电图中识别ST段抬高型心肌梗死(STEMI)患者的现有标准具有高特异性(SP),但敏感性(SE)较低。在我们之前的研究中,我们发现通过从12导联心电图计算3个“最佳”血管特异性导联(VSL)中的ST段偏移,缺血检测的SE可显著提高,且不损失SP。我们最初基于ΔST体表电位图(BSPM)的VSL已通过使用缺血高峰期更合适的J点BSPM进行了修改(不减去闭塞前分布)。本研究的目的是比较这些新VSL与当前实践中使用的STEMI标准的性能。
使用了两个独立的12导联心电图数据集:STAFF III数据集,采集自左前降支(LAD,n = 35)、右冠状动脉(RCA,n = 47)和左旋支(LCx,n = 17)冠状动脉球囊扩张引起的缺血发作期间;以及格拉斯哥数据集,包括116例因胸痛住院并接受对比增强心脏磁共振成像的患者的入院12导联心电图,其中58例(50%)确诊为急性心肌梗死(AMI)。
我们发现,在STAFF III数据集中,STEMI标准检测缺血状态的SE/SP为60/97%,而VSL的SE/SP值为72/98%。在格拉斯哥数据集中,STEMI标准的SE/SP为43/98%,而VSL将SE/SP提高到60/98%。诊断性能最显著的提高出现在LCx冠状动脉闭塞的患者中:在STAFF III数据(n = 17)中,STEMI标准的SE为35%,VSL将其提高到71%;在格拉斯哥数据(n = 12)中,STEMI标准的SE为31%,VSL将其提高到69%。
在我们的研究人群中,现有ACC/ESC STEMI标准辅以新的VSL可显著提高缺血检测的敏感性,且对特异性无任何不利影响。这一发现需要在更大的具有典型急性缺血患病率的胸痛患者人群中得到证实,这些患者在急诊室就诊。