Cervinka Tomas, Sievänen Harri, Lala Deena, Cheung Angela M, Giangregorio Lora, Hyttinen Jari
Department of Electronics and Communications Engineering, Tampere University of Technology, Korkeakoulunkatu 3, 33720 Tampere, Finland; Institute of Bioscience and Medical Technology (BioMediTech), Tampere, Finland.
Bone Research Group, UKK Institute, Kaupinpuistonkatu 1, 33500 Tampere, Finland.
Bone. 2015 Dec;81:721-730. doi: 10.1016/j.bone.2015.09.015. Epub 2015 Sep 30.
High-resolution peripheral quantitative computed tomography (HR-pQCT) is now considered the leading imaging modality in bone research. However, access to HR-pQCT is limited and image acquisition is mainly constrained only for the distal third of appendicular bones. Hence, the conventional pQCT is still commonly used despite inaccurate threshold-based segmentation of cortical bone that can compromise the assessment of whole bone strength. Therefore, this study addressed whether the use of an advanced image processing algorithm, called OBS, can enhance the cortical bone analysis in pQCT images and provide similar information to HR-pQCT when the same volumes of interest are analyzed. Using pQCT images of European Forearm Phantom (EFP), and pQCT and HR-pQCT images of the distal tibia from 15 cadavers, we compared the results from the OBS algorithm with those obtained from common pQCT analyses, HR-pQCT manual analysis (considered as a gold standard) and common HR-pQCT analysis dual threshold technique.We found that the use of OBS segmentation method for pQCT image analysis of EFP data did not result in any improvement but reached similar performance in cortical bone delineation as did HR-pQCT image analyses. The assessments of cortical cross-sectional bone area and thickness by OBS algorithm were overestimated by less than 4% while area moments of inertia were overestimated by ~5–10%, depending on reference HR-pQCT analysis method. In conclusion, this study showed that the OBS algorithm performed reasonably well and it offers a promising practical tool to enhance the assessment of cortical bone geometry in pQCT.
高分辨率外周定量计算机断层扫描(HR-pQCT)现在被认为是骨研究中的领先成像方式。然而,HR-pQCT的使用受限,图像采集主要仅局限于四肢骨的远侧三分之一。因此,尽管基于阈值的皮质骨分割不准确可能会影响对全骨强度的评估,但传统的pQCT仍被广泛使用。因此,本研究探讨了使用一种名为OBS的先进图像处理算法是否可以增强pQCT图像中的皮质骨分析,并在分析相同感兴趣体积时提供与HR-pQCT相似的信息。使用欧洲前臂模型(EFP)的pQCT图像以及15具尸体胫骨远端的pQCT和HR-pQCT图像,我们将OBS算法的结果与普通pQCT分析、HR-pQCT手动分析(视为金标准)和普通HR-pQCT分析双阈值技术的结果进行了比较。我们发现,将OBS分割方法用于EFP数据的pQCT图像分析并未带来任何改善,但在皮质骨描绘方面达到了与HR-pQCT图像分析相似的性能。根据参考HR-pQCT分析方法,OBS算法对皮质骨横截面积和厚度的评估高估不到4%,而惯性矩面积高估约5%-10%。总之,本研究表明OBS算法表现良好,它为增强pQCT中皮质骨几何形状的评估提供了一个有前景的实用工具。