Hyldgaard Morten, Meyer Rikke L, Peng Min, Hibberd Ashley A, Fischer Jana, Sigmundsson Arnar, Mygind Tina
Biofilm Group, Interdisciplinary Nanoscience Center, Aarhus University, Gustav Wieds Vej 14, 8000 Aarhus C, Denmark; Antimicrobial & Antioxidant Development, Nutrition & Health, DuPont, Edwin Rahrs Vej 38, 8220 Brabrand, Denmark.
Biofilm Group, Interdisciplinary Nanoscience Center, Aarhus University, Gustav Wieds Vej 14, 8000 Aarhus C, Denmark.
Int J Food Microbiol. 2015 Dec 23;215:131-42. doi: 10.1016/j.ijfoodmicro.2015.09.014. Epub 2015 Sep 25.
Proliferation of microbial population on fresh poultry meat over time elicits spoilage when reaching unacceptable levels, during which process slime production, microorganism colony formation, negative organoleptic impact and meat structure change are observed. Spoilage organisms in raw meat, especially Gram-negative bacteria can be difficult to combat due to their cell wall composition. In this study, the natural antimicrobial agents ε-poly-L-lysine (ε-PL) and isoeugenol were tested individually and in combinations for their activities against a selection of Gram-negative strains in vitro. All combinations resulted in additive interactions between ε-PL and isoeugenol towards the bacteria tested. The killing efficiency of different ratios of the two antimicrobial agents was further evaluated in vitro against Pseudomonas putida. Subsequently, the most efficient ratio was applied to a raw turkey meat model system which was incubated for 96 h at spoilage temperature. Half of the samples were challenged with P. putida, and the bacterial load and microbial community composition was followed over time. CFU counts revealed that the antimicrobial blend was able to lower the amount of viable Pseudomonas spp. by one log compared to untreated samples of challenged turkey meat, while the single compounds had no effect on the population. However, the compounds had no effect on Pseudomonas spp. CFU in unchallenged meat. Next-generation sequencing offered culture-independent insight into population diversity and changes in microbial composition of the meat during spoilage and in response to antimicrobial treatment. Spoilage of unchallenged turkey meat resulted in decreasing species diversity over time, regardless of whether the samples received antimicrobial treatment. The microbiota composition of untreated unchallenged meat progressed from a Pseudomonas spp. to a Pseudomonas spp., Photobacterium spp., and Brochothrix thermosphacta dominated food matrix on the expense of low abundance species. We observed a similar shift among the dominant species in meat treated with ε-PL or the antimicrobial blend, but the samples differed markedly in the composition of less abundant species. In contrast, the overall species diversity was constant during incubation of turkey meat challenged with P. putida although the microbiota composition did change over time. Untreated or ε-PL treated samples progressed from a Pseudomonas spp. to a Pseudomonas spp. and Enterobacteriaceae dominated food matrix, while treatment with the antimicrobial blend resulted in increased relative abundance of Hafnia spp., Enterococcaceae, and Photobacterium spp. We conclude that the blend delayed the onset of spoilage of challenged meat, and that all antimicrobial treatments of unchallenged or challenged meat affect the progression of the microbial community composition. Our study confirms that the antimicrobial effects observed in vitro can be extrapolated to a food matrix such as turkey meat. However, it also underlines the consequence of species-to-species variation in susceptibility to antimicrobials, namely that the microbial community change while the CFU remains the same. Addition of antimicrobials may thus prevent the growth of some microorganisms, allowing others to proliferate in their place.
随着时间的推移,新鲜禽肉上微生物种群的增殖达到不可接受的水平时会引发腐败,在此过程中会观察到黏液产生、微生物菌落形成、负面感官影响和肉质结构变化。生肉中的腐败微生物,尤其是革兰氏阴性菌,由于其细胞壁组成,可能难以对抗。在本研究中,分别测试了天然抗菌剂ε-聚-L-赖氨酸(ε-PL)和异丁香酚及其组合对一系列革兰氏阴性菌株的体外活性。所有组合在ε-PL和异丁香酚对受试细菌的作用上产生了相加相互作用。进一步在体外评估了两种抗菌剂不同比例对恶臭假单胞菌的杀灭效率。随后,将最有效的比例应用于生火鸡肉模型系统,该系统在腐败温度下孵育96小时。一半的样品用恶臭假单胞菌进行挑战,并随时间跟踪细菌载量和微生物群落组成。菌落形成单位计数显示,与未处理的受挑战火鸡肉样品相比,抗菌混合物能够将可存活的假单胞菌属数量降低一个对数级,而单一化合物对菌量没有影响。然而,这些化合物对未受挑战肉中的假单胞菌属菌落形成单位没有影响。下一代测序提供了与培养无关的见解,可了解肉类在腐败过程中以及对抗菌处理的反应中微生物组成的种群多样性和变化。无论样品是否接受抗菌处理,未受挑战的火鸡肉的腐败都会导致物种多样性随时间下降。未处理的未受挑战肉的微生物群组成从以假单胞菌属为主转变为以假单胞菌属、发光杆菌属和嗜热栖热菌为主的食物基质,低丰度物种减少。我们在经ε-PL或抗菌混合物处理的肉中观察到优势物种之间有类似的转变,但样品在低丰度物种的组成上有明显差异。相比之下,在用恶臭假单胞菌挑战的火鸡肉孵育期间,尽管微生物群组成确实随时间变化,但总体物种多样性保持不变。未处理或经ε-PL处理的样品从以假单胞菌属为主转变为以假单胞菌属和肠杆菌科为主的食物基质,而用抗菌混合物处理导致哈夫尼亚菌属、肠球菌科和发光杆菌属的相对丰度增加。我们得出结论,该混合物延迟了受挑战肉类腐败的开始,并且对未受挑战或受挑战肉类的所有抗菌处理都会影响微生物群落组成的变化。我们的研究证实,在体外观察到的抗菌效果可以外推到火鸡肉等食物基质中。然而,它也强调了不同物种对抗菌剂敏感性差异的后果,即微生物群落发生变化而菌落形成单位保持不变。因此,添加抗菌剂可能会阻止一些微生物的生长,从而使其他微生物得以取而代之增殖。