Chou C-K
a C-K. Chou Consulting , Dublin , CA , USA.
Electromagn Biol Med. 2015 Sep;34(3):175-9. doi: 10.3109/15368378.2015.1076439.
Although there is scientific consensus that radiofrequency (RF) exposure at high intensity can cause thermal effects, including well-established adverse health effects, there is still considerable controversy on whether low-intensity RF exposure can cause biological effects, especially adverse health effects. The objective of this paper is to describe several reported "non-thermal" effects that were later shown to be due to a weak thermal effect or an experimental artifact by properly conducted and thorough follow-on scientific research. First, the multiple factors that can cause different RF energy absorption in biological tissues are reviewed and second, several examples of experimental artifacts in published papers are described to demonstrate the importance of paying attention to dosimetry and temperature control. For example, isolated nerve response studies show that when temperature of the RF-exposed tissues is controlled, effects disappeared. During RF exposure, conductive electrodes routinely used in physiological studies have been shown to cause field intensification at the tips or contacts of the electrodes with biological tissue; thus, the RF exposure at the site of measurement could be much higher than the incident field. In some in vitro studies, a lack of temperature uniformity in RF-exposed cell cultures and rate of heating explain changes originally reported to be due to low-level RF exposure. In other studies, detailed dosimetry studies have identified artifacts that explain the reasons why so-called "non-thermal" effects were mistakenly reported. Researchers should look for explanations for their own findings, and not expect others to figure out what was the reason for their observed effects.
虽然科学界已达成共识,高强度射频(RF)暴露会产生热效应,包括已明确的不良健康影响,但对于低强度RF暴露是否会产生生物效应,尤其是不良健康影响,仍存在相当大的争议。本文的目的是描述一些已报道的“非热”效应,这些效应后来通过适当开展的深入后续科学研究表明是由微弱热效应或实验假象所致。首先,回顾了可导致生物组织中不同RF能量吸收的多种因素,其次,描述了已发表论文中的几个实验假象实例,以证明关注剂量测定和温度控制的重要性。例如,离体神经反应研究表明,当对暴露于RF的组织温度进行控制时,效应就会消失。在RF暴露期间,生理研究中常规使用的导电电极已被证明会在电极尖端或与生物组织的接触点处导致场增强;因此,测量部位的RF暴露可能远高于入射场。在一些体外研究中,暴露于RF的细胞培养物中缺乏温度均匀性以及加热速率解释了最初报道的因低水平RF暴露而产生的变化。在其他研究中,详细的剂量测定研究已确定了假象,这些假象解释了为何会错误地报道所谓的“非热”效应。研究人员应自行寻找其研究结果的解释,而不应期望他人弄清楚其观察到的效应的原因。