Basson Annalie, Olivier Benita, Ellis Richard, Coppieters Michel, Stewart Aimee, Mudzi Witness
1 Department of Physiotherapy, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of the Witwatersrand, South Africa2 The Witwatersrand Centre for Evidence-based Practice: a Collaborating Centre of the Joanna Briggs Institute, South Africa3 School of Rehabilitation and Occupation Studies, Auckland University of Technology, New Zealand4 Faculty of Human Movement Science, Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, The Netherlands.
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015 Jan;13(1):65-75. doi: 10.11124/jbisrir-2015-1401.
REVIEW QUESTION/OBJECTIVE: The objective of this review is to identify the effectiveness of neural mobilization techniques in various neuro-musculoskeletal conditions. Outcomes will be analyzed in terms of subgroups such as low back pain, cervico-brachial pain and carpal tunnel syndrome.
Musculoskeletal disorders were ranked as the second largest contributor to disability worldwide in a study on the global burden of disease. Low back pain and neck pain contributed to 70% of disability in this comprehensive population-based study. Low back pain and neck pain are multifactorial, with heterogeneous populations. It has been proposed that targeting subgroups of patients may result in better treatment outcomes. Neck pain associated with upper limb pain is prevalent. These patients are more disabled than patients with neck pain alone. Similarly, low back pain with leg pain is a common phenomenon and is acknowledged as a predictor for chronicity.Neuropathic pain is often associated with musculoskeletal complaints including low back pain, whiplash associated disorders (WAD) and acute or chronic radiculopathy, and can be a feature of syndromes such as cervico-brachial pain syndrome. According to the International Association for the Study of Pain, neuropathic pain can be described as "pain caused by a lesion or disease of the somatosensory nervous system." Leg pain associated with back pain can be caused by central sensitization, denervation, nerve sensitization or somatically referred pain. In patients with WAD, neck pain is the most common symptom, but upper limb pain, weakness, paraesthesia and anesthesia are often present. Other conditions in which neural tissue is thought to contribute to the clinical picture are, for instance, lateral epicondalalgia and carpal tunnel syndrome.Management strategies for back pain and neck pain are often multimodal. However, the evidence for effective treatment of nerve related pain is lacking. Neural mobilizations are often used to affect the neural structures in conditions with signs of neural involvement or neural mechano-sensitivity. Neural mobilizations are defined as interventions aimed at affecting the neural structures or surrounding tissue (interface) directly or indirectly through manual techniques or exercise. Neural mobilizations have been studied in various populations such as low back pain, carpal tunnel syndrome, lateral epicondalalgia and cervico-brachial pain. Neural mobilization techniques studied include cervical lateral glides for cervico-brachial pain, nerve gliding exercises for the treatment of carpal tunnel syndrome, cervical lateral glides for lateral epicondalalgia and the slump as a neural mobilization technique in the treatment of low back pain. No specialized equipment is needed in the performance of neural mobilization techniques, which contributes to its popularity.Neural mobilization is said to affect the axoplasmic flow, movement of the nerve and its connective tissue and the circulation of the nerve by alteration of the pressure in the nervous system and dispersion of intraneural oedema. Neural mobilization decreases the excitability of dorsal horn cells. Neural mobilizations can be performed in various ways using passive movement, manual mobilization of the nerve or interface, and exercise. The aim of neural mobilization is to restore the mechanical and neurophysiological function of the nerve.Only one systematic review on the effectiveness of neural mobilizations could be identified in the literature. Since this review, several more studies have been published on this subject. The authors hypothesize that a review of the more recent literature (2008-2014) may confirm positive support for the use of neural mobilizations for neuro-musculoskeletal complaints as previously seen by Ellis and Hing. This review aims to include a meta-analysis and subgrouping of conditions which will be an extension of the previous review by Ellis and Hing. The outcomes of this systematic review may be used to inform clinical practice and the development of best practice guidelines.
综述问题/目标:本综述的目的是确定神经松动技术在各种神经肌肉骨骼疾病中的有效性。将根据诸如腰痛、颈臂痛和腕管综合征等亚组来分析结果。
在一项关于全球疾病负担的研究中,肌肉骨骼疾病被列为全球残疾的第二大原因。在这项基于人群的综合研究中,腰痛和颈痛导致了70%的残疾。腰痛和颈痛是多因素的,涉及不同人群。有人提出,针对患者亚组可能会带来更好的治疗效果。伴有上肢疼痛的颈痛很常见。这些患者比单纯颈痛患者的残疾程度更高。同样,伴有腿痛的腰痛是一种常见现象,并且被认为是慢性化的预测指标。神经病理性疼痛常与包括腰痛、挥鞭样损伤相关疾病(WAD)以及急性或慢性神经根病在内的肌肉骨骼疾病相关,并且可能是颈臂痛综合征等综合征的一个特征。根据国际疼痛研究协会的定义,神经病理性疼痛可被描述为“由躯体感觉神经系统的损伤或疾病引起的疼痛”。与背痛相关的腿痛可能由中枢敏化、失神经支配、神经敏化或躯体牵涉痛引起。在WAD患者中,颈痛是最常见的症状,但上肢疼痛、无力、感觉异常和麻木也经常出现。其他被认为神经组织与临床表现有关的疾病,例如,肱骨外上髁炎和腕管综合征。
腰痛和颈痛的管理策略通常是多模式的。然而,缺乏有效治疗神经相关疼痛的证据。神经松动术常用于有神经受累体征或神经机械敏感性的疾病中以影响神经结构。神经松动术被定义为通过手法技术或运动直接或间接影响神经结构或周围组织(界面)的干预措施。神经松动术已在各种人群中进行了研究,如腰痛、腕管综合征、肱骨外上髁炎和颈臂痛患者。所研究的神经松动技术包括用于颈臂痛的颈椎侧方滑动、用于治疗腕管综合征的神经滑动练习、用于肱骨外上髁炎的颈椎侧方滑动以及作为治疗腰痛的神经松动技术的垂头弯腰试验。进行神经松动技术不需要专门的设备,这有助于其普及。
据说神经松动术通过改变神经系统内的压力和消散神经内水肿来影响轴浆流动、神经及其结缔组织的运动以及神经的血液循环。神经松动术可降低背角细胞的兴奋性。神经松动术可以通过被动运动、对神经或界面的手法松动以及运动等多种方式进行。神经松动术的目的是恢复神经的机械和神经生理功能。
在文献中仅能找到一项关于神经松动术有效性的系统综述。自该综述发表以来,关于这个主题又发表了几项研究。作者假设,对最新文献(2008 - 2014年)的综述可能会如埃利斯和欣之前所见那样,证实对使用神经松动术治疗神经肌肉骨骼疾病的积极支持。本综述旨在进行荟萃分析并对疾病进行亚组分析,这将是埃利斯和欣之前综述的扩展。本系统综述的结果可用于为临床实践和最佳实践指南的制定提供参考。