Majid Norhaini, Lee Susan, Plummer Virginia
1 Monash University, School of Nursing and Midwifery, Victoria, Australia2 The Centre for Chronic Disease Management: a Collaborating centre of The Joanna Briggs Institute.
JBI Database System Rev Implement Rep. 2015 Jan;13(1):122-33. doi: 10.11124/jbisrir-2015-1950.
The objective of this review is to identify the effectiveness of patient education for orthopedic surgery patients. More specifically, the objectives are to identify the effectiveness of patient education on:length of staysatisfactionpain levelcost of carefunctional abilitiesknowledgeanxietyquality of life in orthopedic settings.
Patient education is an essential part of practice for all healthcare professionals. In the orthopedic setting, effective patient education contributes to positive patient outcomes. Patient education is critical to ensure that patients receive appropriate information to assist in the pre-admission, peri-operative treatment and rehabilitation process for the patient. The process of patient education is essentially one where the patient comes to understand his or her physical condition and self-care using the experience and guidance of the multidisciplinary team.With an effective and well-structured patient education program, the cost benefit for health care provider and patient includes a shortened length of stay, and reduced cost of care. According to Huang et al. a simplified pre-operative education program reduced the length of stay and cost of care. Similarly, Jones et al. found that length of stay of a patient who received pre-operative education was reduced. In that study, the mean length of stay was significantly reduced from seven days in patients who did not received pre-operative education to five days in patients who received pre-operative education. These results suggest that pre-operative education programs are an effective method in reducing the length of stay of orthopedic patients.Johansson et al. also described pre-operative education for orthopedic patients in a systematic review published in 2005. They discussed the effect of patient education on the orthopedic patient and found that knowledge, anxiety, pain, length of hospital stay, performance of exercise and mobilization, self-efficacy, patient compliance, adherence and empowerment were all improved as a result of patient education. While Johansson et al. included studies up to 2003, the proposed systematic review will include studies from 2003 to 2013.Kruzik also reported benefits of decreased length of stay, reduced pain medication requested post-operatively together with increased patient and family member satisfaction. Bastable reported benefits of patient education, including increased patient satisfaction, improved quality of life, enhanced continuity of care, decreased anxiety, fewer complications, promotion of adherence to the plan of care, maximized independence, and empowerment.Types of education involved in this systematic review are patient education, pre-operative education, and discharge education. Only one study discussed discharge education and the outcome from this review. The outcomes that have been discussed in this systematic review include length of stay, satisfaction, pain level,, 21 cost of care, functional abilities, knowledge, anxiety, and quality of life.Major outcomes discussed in these studies are length of stay, pain,, 21 functional abilities, and anxiety. Most of these studies found significant results of reduced length of stay on those patients who received patient education compared to patient who did not received any patient education or information. Studies support the positive outcomes around length of stay.Common orthopedic conditions that have been discussed are osteoarthritis with total arthroplasty either hip or knee or joint replacement. A study on spinal surgery patients and the effects of pre-operative education, which stated that although there are many studies on the effectiveness on patient education, there are missing data on spinal surgery. This study found that the implementation of patient education has positive impacts upon patient satisfaction especially in managing pain.This review will look specifically at the effectiveness of orthopedic patient education for length of stay, satisfaction, pain level, cost of care, functional ability, knowledge, anxiety, and quality of life.
本综述的目的是确定针对骨科手术患者的患者教育的有效性。更具体地说,目标是确定患者教育在以下方面的有效性:住院时间、满意度、疼痛程度、护理费用、功能能力、知识水平、焦虑程度、骨科环境中的生活质量。
患者教育是所有医疗保健专业人员实践的重要组成部分。在骨科领域,有效的患者教育有助于患者获得积极的治疗结果。患者教育对于确保患者获得适当信息以协助其入院前、围手术期治疗和康复过程至关重要。患者教育过程本质上是患者利用多学科团队的经验和指导来了解自己身体状况和自我护理的过程。通过有效的、结构良好的患者教育计划,医疗保健提供者和患者的成本效益包括缩短住院时间和降低护理费用。根据黄等人的研究,简化的术前教育计划缩短了住院时间并降低了护理费用。同样,琼斯等人发现接受术前教育的患者住院时间缩短。在该研究中,平均住院时间从未接受术前教育的患者的七天显著缩短至接受术前教育的患者的五天。这些结果表明术前教育计划是缩短骨科患者住院时间的有效方法。约翰松等人在2005年发表的一项系统综述中也描述了骨科患者的术前教育。他们讨论了患者教育对骨科患者的影响,发现患者教育使知识水平、焦虑程度、疼痛程度、住院时间、运动和活动能力、自我效能感、患者依从性、坚持性和赋权等方面均得到改善。虽然约翰松等人纳入的研究截至2003年,但本拟进行的系统综述将纳入2003年至2013年的研究。克鲁齐克还报告了住院时间缩短、术后所需止痛药物减少以及患者和家庭成员满意度提高等益处。巴斯塔布尔报告了患者教育的益处,包括患者满意度提高、生活质量改善、护理连续性增强、焦虑减轻、并发症减少、促进对护理计划的坚持、最大限度地提高独立性以及赋权。本系统综述涉及的教育类型包括患者教育、术前教育和出院教育。只有一项研究讨论了出院教育及其综述结果。本系统综述中讨论的结果包括住院时间、满意度、疼痛程度、护理费用、功能能力、知识水平、焦虑程度和生活质量。这些研究中讨论的主要结果是住院时间、疼痛、功能能力和焦虑。这些研究中的大多数发现,与未接受任何患者教育或信息的患者相比,接受患者教育的患者住院时间显著缩短。研究支持了在住院时间方面的积极结果。已讨论的常见骨科病症包括髋或膝关节置换或关节置换的骨关节炎。一项关于脊柱手术患者及术前教育效果的研究指出,尽管有许多关于患者教育有效性的研究,但脊柱手术方面存在数据缺失。该研究发现患者教育的实施对患者满意度有积极影响,尤其是在疼痛管理方面。本综述将具体探讨骨科患者教育在住院时间、满意度、疼痛程度、护理费用、功能能力、知识水平、焦虑程度和生活质量方面的有效性。