Haak Daniel, Page Charles-E, Deserno Thomas M
Department of Medical Informatics, Uniklinik RWTH Aachen, Pauwelsstr. 30, D-52057, Aachen, Germany.
J Digit Imaging. 2016 Apr;29(2):206-15. doi: 10.1007/s10278-015-9833-1.
The digital imaging and communications in medicine (DICOM) protocol is the leading standard for image data management in healthcare. Imaging biomarkers and image-based surrogate endpoints in clinical trials and medical registries require DICOM viewer software with advanced functionality for visualization and interfaces for integration. In this paper, a comprehensive evaluation of 28 DICOM viewers is performed. The evaluation criteria are obtained from application scenarios in clinical research rather than patient care. They include (i) platform, (ii) interface, (iii) support, (iv) two-dimensional (2D), and (v) three-dimensional (3D) viewing. On the average, 4.48 and 1.43 of overall 8 2D and 5 3D image viewing criteria are satisfied, respectively. Suitable DICOM interfaces for central viewing in hospitals are provided by GingkoCADx, MIPAV, and OsiriX Lite. The viewers ImageJ, MicroView, MIPAV, and OsiriX Lite offer all included 3D-rendering features for advanced viewing. Interfaces needed for decentral viewing in web-based systems are offered by Oviyam, Weasis, and Xero. Focusing on open source components, MIPAV is the best candidate for 3D imaging as well as DICOM communication. Weasis is superior for workflow optimization in clinical trials. Our evaluation shows that advanced visualization and suitable interfaces can also be found in the open source field and not only in commercial products.
医学数字成像和通信(DICOM)协议是医疗保健领域图像数据管理的主要标准。临床试验和医学注册中的成像生物标志物及基于图像的替代终点需要具备先进可视化功能的DICOM查看器软件以及用于集成的接口。本文对28款DICOM查看器进行了全面评估。评估标准源自临床研究的应用场景而非患者护理。这些标准包括:(i)平台;(ii)接口;(iii)支持;(iv)二维(2D)查看;以及(v)三维(3D)查看。平均而言,在总共8项2D图像查看标准和5项3D图像查看标准中,分别有4.48项和1.43项得到满足。GingkoCADx、MIPAV和OsiriX Lite提供了适用于医院集中查看的DICOM接口。ImageJ、MicroView、MIPAV和OsiriX Lite这几款查看器具备所有纳入的3D渲染功能,可实现高级查看。Oviyam、Weasis和Xero提供了基于网络系统中分散查看所需的接口。聚焦于开源组件,MIPAV是3D成像以及DICOM通信的最佳选择。Weasis在优化临床试验工作流程方面表现出色。我们的评估表明,先进的可视化功能和合适的接口不仅在商业产品中可以找到,在开源领域也能找到。