Kibbe Melissa M, Feigenson Lisa
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Boston University, 64 Cummington Mall, Boston, MA 02215, USA; Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N Charles St, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA.
Department of Psychological and Brain Sciences, Johns Hopkins University, 3400 N Charles St, Baltimore, MD 21218, USA.
Cognition. 2016 Jan;146:251-63. doi: 10.1016/j.cognition.2015.09.022. Epub 2015 Nov 9.
Infants, like adults, can maintain only a few items in working memory, but can overcome this limit by creating more efficient representations, or "chunks." Previous research shows that infants can form chunks using shared features or spatial proximity between objects. Here we asked whether infants also can create chunked representations using regularities that unfold over time. Thirteen-month old infants first were familiarized with four objects of different shapes and colors, presented in successive pairs. For some infants, the identities of objects in each pair varied randomly across familiarization (Experiment 1). For others, the objects within a pair always co-occurred, either in consistent relative spatial positions (Experiment 2a) or varying spatial positions (Experiment 2b). Following familiarization, infants saw all four objects hidden behind a screen and then saw the screen lifted to reveal either four objects or only three. Infants in Experiment 1, who had been familiarized with random object pairings, failed to look longer at the unexpected 3-object outcome; they showed the same inability to concurrently represent four objects as in other studies of infant working memory. In contrast, infants in Experiments 2a and 2b, who had been familiarized with regularly co-occurring pairs, looked longer at the unexpected outcome. These infants apparently used the co-occurrence between individual objects during familiarization to form chunked representations that were later deployed to track the objects as they were hidden at test. In Experiment 3, we confirmed that the familiarization affected infants' ability to remember the occluded objects rather than merely establishing longer-term memory for object pairs. Following familiarization to consistent pairs, infants who were not shown a hiding event (but merely saw the same test outcomes as in Experiments 2a and b) showed no preference for arrays of three versus four objects. Finally, in Experiments 4 and 5, we asked whether infants also remembered the specific identities of the objects in each chunk. In Experiment 4, we confirmed that infants remembered objects' identities in smaller arrays that did not require chunking. Next, in Experiment 5, we asked whether infants also remembered objects' identities in larger arrays that had been chunked on the basis of temporal regularities. Following a familiarization phase identical to that in Experiment 2a, we hid all four objects and then revealed either these same four objects, or four objects of which two had unexpectedly changed shape and color. Surprisingly, infants failed to look longer at the identity change outcome. Taken together, our results suggest that infants can use temporal regularities between objects to increase memory for objects' existence, but not necessarily for objects' identities.
婴儿和成人一样,工作记忆中只能保存少量物品,但他们可以通过创建更有效的表征,即“组块”来克服这一限制。先前的研究表明,婴儿可以利用物体之间的共同特征或空间邻近性来形成组块。在这里,我们探讨婴儿是否也能利用随时间展开的规律来创建组块表征。13个月大的婴儿首先熟悉四个不同形状和颜色的物体,这些物体以连续的两两组合形式呈现。对于一些婴儿,每对物体的身份在熟悉过程中随机变化(实验1)。对于另一些婴儿,一对物体总是同时出现,要么处于一致的相对空间位置(实验2a),要么处于变化的空间位置(实验2b)。熟悉之后,婴儿看到所有四个物体被藏在一个屏幕后面,然后看到屏幕升起,露出四个物体或者只有三个物体。实验1中的婴儿,他们熟悉的是随机的物体配对,对于意外的三个物体结果并没有更长时间的注视;他们表现出与其他婴儿工作记忆研究中相同的无法同时表征四个物体的情况。相比之下,实验2a和2b中的婴儿,他们熟悉的是经常同时出现的配对,对意外结果注视时间更长。这些婴儿显然在熟悉过程中利用单个物体之间的同时出现来形成组块表征,随后在测试中当物体被藏起来时,利用这些组块表征来追踪物体。在实验3中,我们证实熟悉过程影响了婴儿记住被遮挡物体的能力,而不仅仅是建立对物体配对的长期记忆。在熟悉了一致的配对之后,没有看到隐藏事件(但只是看到与实验2a和b相同的测试结果)的婴儿对三个物体和四个物体的排列没有偏好。最后,在实验4和5中,我们探讨婴儿是否也记住了每个组块中物体的具体身份。在实验4中,我们证实婴儿在不需要组块的较小阵列中记住了物体的身份。接下来,在实验5中,我们探讨婴儿在基于时间规律进行组块的较大阵列中是否也记住了物体的身份。在经历了与实验2a相同的熟悉阶段后,我们藏起所有四个物体,然后露出这相同的四个物体,或者露出四个物体,其中两个物体的形状和颜色意外地发生了变化。令人惊讶的是,婴儿对身份变化结果并没有更长时间的注视。综合来看,我们的结果表明婴儿可以利用物体之间的时间规律来增加对物体存在的记忆,但不一定能记住物体的身份。