Vijayasarathi Arvind, Hawkins C Matthew, Hughes Danny R, Mullins Mark E, Duszak Richard
1 Department of Radiology and Imaging Services, Emory University School of Medicine, 1364 Clifton Rd, NE Ste D125A, Atlanta, GA 30322.
2 Harvey L. Neiman Health Policy Institute, American College of Radiology, Reston, VA.
AJR Am J Roentgenol. 2015 Nov;205(5):929-35. doi: 10.2214/AJR.14.14167.
The objective of this study was to gauge the knowledge of radiology trainees regarding the costs of common imaging services and to assess their perceptions of current relevant education.
During mid-2014, an online survey of 5325 U.S. residents and fellows who were members of the American College of Radiology was conducted. Respondents were asked to provide information about year of training, relevant advanced degrees (e.g., Master of Business Administration or Master of Public Health), number of hours of formal education in health care economics provided annually by their training program, self-perception of knowledge of health care economics, and desire to learn more about the costs of imaging. Respondents were asked to estimate Medicare-allowable fees for five commonly performed imaging examinations: two-view chest radiography, contrast-enhanced CT of the abdomen and pelvis, unenhanced MRI of the lumbar spine, complete abdominal ultrasound, and unenhanced CT of the brain. Responses within ± 25% of published allowable amounts in the Medicare fee schedule were deemed correct.
A total of 1066 of 5325 trainees (20.0%) returned surveys that were sufficiently complete for analysis. Only 17.1% of all responses were correct; 65.3% of responses were overestimations of actual costs, and 17.6% were underestimations. Almost half of the trainees (45.1%) incorrectly estimated the cost of every examination. Overall, knowledge of costs of examinations did not improve with advancing years of training, hours of education in health care economics, or attainment of a relevant advanced degree. Only 9.3% of trainees considered their knowledge of imaging costs to be adequate. An overwhelming 89.7% of trainees desired more focused education.
Radiology trainees have limited knowledge of the costs of commonly performed imaging studies. Effective training program curricula currently appear to be lacking. Targeted education and integration of cost information into clinical decision support tools are probably warranted.
本研究的目的是评估放射科住院医师对常见影像检查费用的了解程度,并评估他们对当前相关教育的看法。
2014年年中,对5325名美国放射学会会员中的住院医师和研究员进行了在线调查。受访者被要求提供有关培训年份、相关高级学位(如工商管理硕士或公共卫生硕士)、培训项目每年提供的卫生保健经济学正规教育时长、对卫生保健经济学知识的自我认知以及对了解更多影像检查费用的渴望等信息。受访者被要求估算五项常见影像检查的医疗保险允许费用:胸部双视图X线摄影、腹部和盆腔增强CT、腰椎平扫MRI、全腹部超声以及脑部平扫CT。医疗保险费用表中公布的允许金额上下浮动25%以内的回答被视为正确。
5325名受训人员中有1066名(20.0%)返回了足够完整以供分析的调查问卷。所有回答中只有17.1%是正确的;65.3%的回答高估了实际费用,17.6%的回答低估了实际费用。几乎一半的受训人员(45.1%)对每项检查的费用估算都不正确。总体而言,随着培训年份的增加、卫生保健经济学教育时长的增加或获得相关高级学位,对检查费用的了解并没有提高。只有9.3%的受训人员认为他们对影像检查费用的了解足够。压倒性的89.7%的受训人员希望接受更有针对性的教育。
放射科住院医师对常见影像检查费用的了解有限。目前似乎缺乏有效的培训项目课程。有针对性的教育以及将费用信息整合到临床决策支持工具中可能是必要的。