Abe Misako, Kurosawa Hideo, Sato Ryo, Ito Kumie, Tomono Yoshiharu, Manita Daisuke, Hirowatari Yuji, Yoshida Hiroshi
Rinsho Byori. 2015 Mar;63(3):312-8.
The LDL-C level measures with homogeneous (direct) assays in almost of clinical laboratories. Several reports however showed differences in measured values among the assay reagents. We investigated the differences in LDL-C values among direct assays and Friedewald formula (F-f) in 58 LP-X positive serum samples from jaundice patients by comparing LDL-C values measured by anion-exchange chromatography (AEX-HPLC), largely comparable to ultracentrifugation method. Changes in LDL-C values during the treatment of 8 patients were also investigated. Direct assay reagents from Sekisui Medical (S-r), Denka-Seiken (D-r), Wako Chemical (W-r), and Kyowa Medics (K-r) were used for comparison. F-f, S-r, and D-r correlated with AEX-HPLC with r values < 0.6 while W-r and K-r correlated with AEX-HPLC with r-vales > 0.6. Two samples in which F-f values provided 500 mg/dL plus bias to AEX-HPLC (LDL-C value of 220 mg/dL) demonstrated increased levels of IDL-C before treatment. LDL-C values (S-r and D-r) of the 2 samples were relatively high and near to F-f data while LDL-C values (W-r and K-r) were relatively low and close to AEX-HPLC data. The jaundice treatment decreased LDL-C values (S-r and D-r) and converged to 220 mg/dL, indicating that S-r and D-r might react markedly to IDL. These changes were consistent with decreases in serum free cholesterol and phospholipid in support of LP-X. By contrast, W-r and K-r data showed upward tendency and also converged to 220 mg/dL. These results suggest that LDL-C direct assay reagents would be classified into 2 groups with respect to the reagent reactivity to LP-X.
几乎所有临床实验室都采用均相(直接)测定法来检测低密度脂蛋白胆固醇(LDL-C)水平。然而,有几份报告显示,不同检测试剂的测量值存在差异。我们通过比较阴离子交换色谱法(AEX-HPLC)测定的LDL-C值(该方法与超速离心法大致相当),研究了58份黄疸患者的LP-X阳性血清样本中直接测定法与Friedewald公式(F-f)之间LDL-C值的差异。我们还研究了8例患者治疗期间LDL-C值的变化。使用了积水医疗株式会社(S-r)、电気化学工业株式会社(D-r)、和光纯药工业株式会社(W-r)以及协和梅迪克公司(K-r)的直接检测试剂进行比较。F-f、S-r和D-r与AEX-HPLC的相关性r值<0.6,而W-r和K-r与AEX-HPLC的相关性r值>0.6。有两个样本,其F-f值相对于AEX-HPLC提供了500mg/dL的正偏差(LDL-C值为220mg/dL),治疗前显示中间密度脂蛋白胆固醇(IDL-C)水平升高。这两个样本的LDL-C值(S-r和D-r)相对较高且接近F-f数据,而LDL-C值(W-r和K-r)相对较低且接近AEX-HPLC数据。黄疸治疗使LDL-C值(S-r和D-r)降低并收敛至220mg/dL,表明S-r和D-r可能对IDL有明显反应。这些变化与血清游离胆固醇和磷脂的减少一致,支持LP-X的存在。相比之下,W-r和K-r的数据呈上升趋势,也收敛至220mg/dL。这些结果表明,就试剂对LP-X的反应性而言,LDL-C直接检测试剂可分为两组。