Young Alexandria, Stillman Richard, Smith Martin J, Korstjens Amanda H
Faculty of Science and Technology, Bournemouth University, BH12 5BB, Bournemouth, U.K.
J Forensic Sci. 2016 Mar;61(2):458-466. doi: 10.1111/1556-4029.12974. Epub 2015 Nov 9.
Forensic investigations involving animal scavenging of human remains require a physical search of the scene and surrounding areas. However, there is currently no standard procedure in the U.K. for physical searches of scavenged human remains. The Winthrop and grid search methods used by police specialist searchers for scavenged remains were examined through the use of mock red fox (Vulpes vulpes) scatter scenes. Forty-two police specialist searchers from two different regions within the U.K. were divided between those briefed and not briefed with fox-typical scavenging information. Briefing searchers with scavenging information significantly affected the recovery of scattered bones (χ(2) = 11.45, df = 1, p = 0.001). Searchers briefed with scavenging information were 2.05 times more likely to recover bones. Adaptions to search methods used by searchers were evident on a regional level, such that searchers more accustom to a peri-urban to rural region recovered a higher percentage of scattered bones (58.33%, n = 84).
涉及动物啃食人尸骸的法医调查需要对现场及周边区域进行实地搜索。然而,目前在英国,对于被动物啃食的人尸骸进行实地搜索尚无标准程序。通过模拟赤狐(Vulpes vulpes)散落场景,对警方专业搜索人员用于搜索被啃食人尸骸的温思罗普搜索法和网格搜索法进行了检验。来自英国两个不同地区的42名警方专业搜索人员被分为两组,一组被告知狐狸典型的啃食信息,另一组未被告知。向搜索人员通报啃食信息对散落骨头的找回有显著影响(χ(2)=11.45,自由度=1,p = 0.001)。被告知啃食信息的搜索人员找回骨头的可能性高出2.05倍。在区域层面上,搜索人员所采用的搜索方法存在明显差异,例如,更习惯城乡结合部到农村地区环境的搜索人员找回的散落骨头比例更高(58.33%,n = 84)。