Souza e Silva Christina G de, Araújo Claudio Gil S
Programa de Pós-Graduação em Cardiologia, Instituto do Coração Edson Saad, Universidade Federal do Rio de Janeiro, Rio de Janeiro, RJ, Brazil.
Arq Bras Cardiol. 2015 Oct;105(4):381-9. doi: 10.5935/abc.20150089. Epub 2015 Jul 31.
Aerobic fitness, assessed by measuring VO2max in maximum cardiopulmonary exercise testing (CPX) or by estimating VO2max through the use of equations in exercise testing, is a predictor of mortality. However, the error resulting from this estimate in a given individual can be high, affecting clinical decisions.
To determine the error of estimate of VO2max in cycle ergometry in a population attending clinical exercise testing laboratories, and to propose sex-specific equations to minimize that error.
This study assessed 1715 adults (18 to 91 years, 68% men) undertaking maximum CPX in a lower limbs cycle ergometer (LLCE) with ramp protocol. The percentage error (E%) between measured VO2max and that estimated from the modified ACSM equation (Lang et al. MSSE, 1992) was calculated. Then, estimation equations were developed: 1) for all the population tested (C-GENERAL); and 2) separately by sex (C-MEN and C-WOMEN).
Measured VO2max was higher in men than in WOMEN: -29.4 ± 10.5 and 24.2 ± 9.2 mL.(kg.min)-1 (p < 0.01). The equations for estimating VO2max [in mL.(kg.min)-1] were: C-GENERAL = [final workload (W)/body weight (kg)] x 10.483 + 7; C-MEN = [final workload (W)/body weight (kg)] x 10.791 + 7; and C-WOMEN = [final workload (W)/body weight (kg)] x 9.820 + 7. The E% for MEN was: -3.4 ± 13.4% (modified ACSM); 1.2 ± 13.2% (C-GENERAL); and -0.9 ± 13.4% (C-MEN) (p < 0.01). For WOMEN: -14.7 ± 17.4% (modified ACSM); -6.3 ± 16.5% (C-GENERAL); and -1.7 ± 16.2% (C-WOMEN) (p < 0.01).
The error of estimate of VO2max by use of sex-specific equations was reduced, but not eliminated, in exercise tests on LLCE.
通过在最大心肺运动测试(CPX)中测量最大摄氧量(VO2max)或在运动测试中使用公式估算VO2max来评估的有氧适能是死亡率的一个预测指标。然而,在特定个体中这种估算所产生的误差可能很大,从而影响临床决策。
确定在临床运动测试实验室进行测试的人群中,下肢蹬车运动测试时VO2max的估算误差,并提出针对性别的公式以尽量减少该误差。
本研究评估了1715名成年人(年龄18至91岁,68%为男性),他们在下肢蹬车测力计(LLCE)上采用斜坡方案进行最大CPX测试。计算测量的VO2max与根据改良的美国运动医学学会(ACSM)公式(Lang等人,《运动科学与医学杂志》,1992年)估算的VO2max之间的百分比误差(E%)。然后,制定了估算公式:1)针对所有测试人群(C - 通用公式);2)按性别分别制定(C - 男性公式和C - 女性公式)。
男性测量的VO2max高于女性:分别为-29.4±10.5和24.2±9.2 mL·(kg·min)-1(p<0.01)。估算VO2max[单位为mL·(kg·min)-1]的公式为:C - 通用公式 = [最终工作量(W)/体重(kg)]×10.483 + 7;C - 男性公式 = [最终工作量(W)/体重(kg)]×10.791 + 7;C - 女性公式 = [最终工作量(W)/体重(kg)]×9.820 + 7。男性的E%分别为:-3.4±13.4%(改良ACSM公式);1.2±13.2%(C - 通用公式);-0.9±13.4%(C - 男性公式)(p<0.01)。女性的E%分别为:-14.7±17.4%(改良ACSM公式);-6.3±16.5%(C - 通用公式);-1.7±16.2%(C - 女性公式)(p<0.01)。
在LLCE运动测试中,使用针对性别的公式可减少但不能消除VO2max的估算误差。