Devaiah Anand, Murchison Charles
Boston Medical Center, Department of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery, Neurologic Surgery, Ophthalmology, Boston, Massachusetts, USA
Boston University School of Medicine, Boston, Massachusetts, USA.
Otolaryngol Head Neck Surg. 2016 Feb;154(2):309-14. doi: 10.1177/0194599815617723. Epub 2015 Nov 17.
To report on types of investigations being conducted in US clinical trials, the types of therapeutic investigations that predominate, and the publication rates.
Retrospective analysis.
US head and neck cancer clinical trials.
We used the information available on ClinicalTrials.gov to identify trends in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma clinical trials to characterize the types of trials and treatments being investigated. The publication rate for these trials was also examined with PubMed.gov.
Of the 473 trials analyzed, similar drug regimens have been used repeatedly in head and neck cancer clinical trials. Drug studies are highly represented, composing 62% of all trials. The most common drugs studied were cisplatin, cetuximab, and docetaxel. Among all head and neck cancer clinical trials, 33% included radiation therapy in their treatment, while 10% included a surgical component. Forty-nine percent of trials had their results published in a medical journal, and 70% of the publications reported positive results.
Head and neck cancer trials are heavily weighted toward drug trials and demonstrate redundancy. Other therapies are underrepresented, especially surgery. There is a gap between the trials conducted and the rate of reporting, with an emphasis on positive results. Better balance in studying treatment modalities, less redundancy in clinical trials, and reporting all results have potential benefits for head and neck cancer and the public good.
报告美国临床试验正在进行的研究类型、占主导地位的治疗性研究类型以及发表率。
回顾性分析。
美国头颈癌临床试验。
我们利用ClinicalTrials.gov上的可用信息,确定头颈鳞状细胞癌临床试验的趋势,以描述正在研究的试验类型和治疗方法。这些试验的发表率也通过PubMed.gov进行了检查。
在分析的473项试验中,类似的药物方案在头颈癌临床试验中被反复使用。药物研究占比很高,占所有试验的62%。研究最多的常见药物是顺铂、西妥昔单抗和多西他赛。在所有头颈癌临床试验中,33%的试验在治疗中包括放射治疗,而10%的试验包括手术部分。49%的试验结果发表在医学杂志上,70%的出版物报告了阳性结果。
头颈癌试验严重偏向药物试验,且存在重复性。其他疗法占比不足,尤其是手术。进行的试验与报告率之间存在差距,且侧重于阳性结果。在研究治疗方式上实现更好的平衡、减少临床试验的重复性以及报告所有结果,对头颈癌和公共利益可能具有潜在益处。