Mendelow A David
Institute of Neuroscience, Neurosurgical Trials Group, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, UK.
Front Neurol Neurosci. 2015;37:148-54. doi: 10.1159/000437119. Epub 2015 Nov 12.
Craniotomy is probably indicated for patients with superficial spontaneous lobar supratentorial intracerebral haemorrhage (ICH) when the level of consciousness drops below 13 within the first 8 h of the onset of the haemorrhage. Once the level drops below 9, it is probably too late to consider craniotomy for these patients, so clinical vigilance is paramount. While this statement is only backed up by evidence that is moderately strong, meta-analysis of available data suggests that it is true in the rather limited number of patients with ICH. Meta-analyses like this can often predict the results of future prospective randomised controlled trials a decade or more before the trials are completed and published. Countless such examples exist in the literature, as is the case for thrombolysis in patients with myocardial infarction in the last millennium: meta-analysis determined the efficacy more than a decade BEFORE the last trial (ISIS-2) confirmed the benefit of thrombolysis for myocardial infarction. Careful examination of the meta-analysis' Forest plots in this chapter will demonstrate why this statement is made at the outset. Other meta-analyses of surgery for ICH have also indicated that minimal interventional techniques using topical thrombolysis or endoscopy via burrholes or even twist drill aspiration may be particularly successful for the treatment of supratentorial ICH, especially when the clot is deep seated. Ongoing clinical trials (CLEAR III and MISTIE III) should confirm this in the fullness of time. There are 2 exceptions to these generalisations. First, based on trial evidence, aneurysmal ICH is best treated with surgery. Second, cerebellar ICH represents a special case because of the development of hydrocephalus, which may require expeditious drainage as the intracranial pressure rises. The cerebellar clot will then require evacuation, usually via posterior fossa craniectomy, rather than craniotomy. Technical advances suggest that image-guided surgery may improve the completeness of surgical evacuation and outcomes, regardless of which surgical technique is employed.
对于自发性幕上脑叶脑出血(ICH)且意识水平在出血发作后8小时内降至13以下的患者,可能需要进行开颅手术。一旦意识水平降至9以下,对这些患者考虑开颅手术可能就为时已晚,因此临床警惕至关重要。虽然这一说法仅得到中等强度证据的支持,但对现有数据的荟萃分析表明,在相当有限的ICH患者中这是正确的。像这样的荟萃分析往往能在未来前瞻性随机对照试验完成并发表前十多年就预测其结果。文献中有无数这样的例子,就像上世纪心肌梗死患者溶栓治疗的情况一样:荟萃分析在最后一项试验(ISIS - 2)证实溶栓对心肌梗死有益之前十多年就确定了其疗效。仔细查看本章荟萃分析的森林图将说明为何一开始会有这样的说法。其他关于ICH手术的荟萃分析也表明,使用局部溶栓或通过钻孔甚至 twist drill 抽吸进行内镜检查的微创技术可能对幕上ICH的治疗特别成功,尤其是当血凝块位置较深时。正在进行的临床试验(CLEAR III和MISTIE III)应迟早证实这一点。这些概括有两个例外。第一,基于试验证据,动脉瘤性ICH最好通过手术治疗。第二,小脑ICH是一种特殊情况,因为会发生脑积水,随着颅内压升高可能需要迅速引流。然后通常需要通过后颅窝颅骨切除术而不是开颅手术来清除小脑血凝块。技术进步表明,无论采用哪种手术技术,图像引导手术可能会提高手术清除的完整性和治疗效果。