Davoren Mary, Byrne Orla, O'Connell Paul, O'Neill Helen, O'Reilly Ken, Kennedy Harry G
Department of Psychiatry, Trinity College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland.
National Forensic Mental Health Service, Central Mental Hospital, Dundrum, Dublin 14, Ireland.
BMC Psychiatry. 2015 Nov 23;15:301. doi: 10.1186/s12888-015-0686-4.
Patients admitted to a secure forensic hospital are at risk of a long hospital stay. Forensic hospital beds are a scarce and expensive resource and ability to identify the factors predicting length of stay at time of admission would be beneficial. The DUNDRUM-1 triage security scale and DUNDRUM-2 triage urgency scale are designed to assess need for therapeutic security and urgency of that need while the HCR-20 predicts risk of violence. We hypothesized that items on the DUNDRUM-1 and DUNDRUM-2 scales, rated at the time of pre-admission assessment, would predict length of stay in a medium secure forensic hospital setting.
This is a prospective study. All admissions to a medium secure forensic hospital setting were collated over a 54 month period (n = 279) and followed up for a total of 66 months. Each patient was rated using the DUNDRUM-1 triage security scale and DUNDRUM-2 triage urgency scale as part of a pre-admission assessment (n = 279) and HCR-20 within 2 weeks of admission (n = 187). Episodes of harm to self, harm to others and episodes of seclusion whilst an in-patient were collated. Date of discharge was noted for each individual.
Diagnosis at the time of pre-admission assessment (adjustment disorder v other diagnosis), predicted legal status (sentenced v mental health order) and items on the DUNDRUM-1 triage security scale and the DUNDRUM-2 triage urgency scale, also rated at the time of pre-admission assessment, predicted length of stay in the forensic hospital setting. Need for seclusion following admission also predicted length of stay.
These findings may form the basis for a structured professional judgment instrument, rated prior to or at time of admission, to assist in estimating length of stay for forensic patients. Such a tool would be useful to clinicians, service planners and commissioners given the high cost of secure psychiatric care.
入住安全型法医医院的患者面临住院时间较长的风险。法医医院床位是一种稀缺且昂贵的资源,若能在入院时识别出预测住院时间的因素将大有裨益。邓德鲁姆-1分诊安全量表和邓德鲁姆-2分诊紧急量表旨在评估治疗安全需求及该需求的紧迫性,而HCR-20则预测暴力风险。我们假设,在入院前评估时评定的邓德鲁姆-1量表和邓德鲁姆-2量表项目可预测在中等安全型法医医院环境中的住院时间。
这是一项前瞻性研究。在54个月期间整理了所有入住中等安全型法医医院的患者(n = 279),并进行了为期66个月的随访。作为入院前评估的一部分,使用邓德鲁姆-1分诊安全量表和邓德鲁姆-2分诊紧急量表对每位患者进行评定(n = 279),并在入院后2周内使用HCR-20进行评定(n = 187)。整理了住院期间的自伤、伤人事件及隔离事件。记录了每位患者的出院日期。
入院前评估时的诊断(适应障碍与其他诊断)可预测法律状态(被判刑与精神健康令),在入院前评估时评定的邓德鲁姆-1分诊安全量表和邓德鲁姆-2分诊紧急量表项目也可预测在法医医院环境中的住院时间。入院后对隔离的需求也可预测住院时间。
这些发现可能构成一种结构化专业判断工具的基础,该工具在入院前或入院时进行评定,以协助估计法医患者的住院时间。鉴于安全精神病护理成本高昂,这样一种工具对临床医生、服务规划者和专员将很有用。