Beecher S M, Donlan C, O'Leary D P, Kerin M J, McLaughlin R
Department of Breast Surgery, Galway University Hospital, Galway, Ireland.
Ir J Med Sci. 2016 Nov;185(4):877-880. doi: 10.1007/s11845-015-1386-2. Epub 2015 Nov 23.
Integration of general practitioners (GPs) into a tertiary care team is a model used internationally to assist with provision of patient care. Symptomatic breast clinics have seen significant increases in attendances and consequential staffing issues. We wished to analyze the integration of GPs into a tertiary breast care team and establish whether their inclusion is a cost-effective approach.
A prospectively maintained database was used to identify 1614 new and 1453 review patients seen in the clinic between September and December 2013. The triple assessment clinical, radiological, and biopsy scores of patients assessed by GPs were compared to those assessed by registrars and to the overall number of patients seen. A cost analysis was performed based on the hourly rates of GPs and registrars.
1614 new patients seen over the 4-month period. GPs reviewed a mean of 153.6 new patients and registrars reviewed a mean of 97.8. Registrars reviewed patients who were allocated higher 'S' scores, with 46 % of patients allocated an S4 and 21 % of patients allocated an S5 score. GPs reviewed a mean of 115.6 return patients and registrars reviewed a mean of 110.1 return patients. The weekly cost of employing 3 GPs for 15 h was €835. This compares favorably to the cost of employing a full-time registrar.
This study demonstrates that GPs can play a substantial role in the provision of a symptomatic breast service. In addition, the incorporation of GPs in this setting can prove cost-effective.
将全科医生(GP)纳入三级医疗团队是一种国际上用于协助提供患者护理的模式。有症状的乳腺诊所就诊人数显著增加,随之出现了人员配备问题。我们希望分析全科医生融入三级乳腺护理团队的情况,并确定纳入他们是否是一种具有成本效益的方法。
使用一个前瞻性维护的数据库来识别2013年9月至12月期间在诊所就诊的1614名新患者和1453名复诊患者。将由全科医生评估的患者的三重评估(临床、放射学和活检)分数与由住院医生评估的分数以及就诊患者的总数进行比较。基于全科医生和住院医生的小时费率进行成本分析。
在4个月期间共诊治了1614名新患者。全科医生平均诊治153.6名新患者,住院医生平均诊治97.8名。住院医生诊治的患者被分配了更高的“S”分数,46%的患者被分配S4分数,21%的患者被分配S5分数。全科医生平均诊治115.6名复诊患者,住院医生平均诊治110.1名复诊患者。每周雇佣3名全科医生工作15小时的成本为835欧元。这比雇佣一名全职住院医生的成本更有利。
本研究表明,全科医生在提供有症状乳腺服务方面可以发挥重要作用。此外,在这种情况下纳入全科医生可证明具有成本效益。