Bredfeldt R C, Sutherland J E, Kruse J E
Department of Family Practice, Southern Illinois University School of Medicine, Springfield.
J Fam Pract. 1989 Aug;29(2):153-6; discussion 157-8.
Thirty patients completed a double-blind, randomized crossover study utilizing transdermal clonidine and an identical-appearing placebo. Crossover occurred at 6 weeks, with a total study time of 12 weeks. Subjects were asked to record daily in a special diary (1) the presence or absence of headache, (2) duration of headache, (3) severity of headache, and (4) use of pain medication for headache relief. The severity of the headaches was rated from 1 (very mild) to 5 (very severe). Although the subjects reported a decrease in frequency, duration, and intensity of headaches while using the medicated patch, these differences did not reach statistical significance. Nineteen patients subjectively preferred the medicated patch, while five preferred the placebo (P less than .01). During use of the medicated patch, a significant reduction (P = .039) occurred in use of class II narcotics. Three doses of these substances were used by the patients when treated with clonidine, while 34 doses were taken during placebo use. These findings suggest that clonidine might have a role in reduction of parenteral narcotic use in acute pain syndromes.
30名患者完成了一项双盲、随机交叉研究,使用了透皮可乐定和外观相同的安慰剂。交叉在6周时进行,总研究时间为12周。受试者被要求每天在一本特殊的日记中记录:(1)是否有头痛;(2)头痛持续时间;(3)头痛严重程度;(4)使用止痛药物缓解头痛的情况。头痛严重程度从1级(非常轻微)到5级(非常严重)进行评定。尽管受试者报告在使用药物贴片时头痛的频率、持续时间和强度有所下降,但这些差异未达到统计学显著性。19名患者主观上更喜欢药物贴片,而5名患者更喜欢安慰剂(P小于0.01)。在使用药物贴片期间,II类麻醉药品的使用量显著减少(P = 0.039)。患者在使用可乐定治疗时使用了3剂这些药物,而在使用安慰剂期间服用了34剂。这些发现表明可乐定可能在急性疼痛综合征中减少胃肠外麻醉药品的使用方面发挥作用。