Edelman E Jennifer, Hansen Nathan B, Cutter Christopher J, Danton Cheryl, Fiellin Lynn E, O'Connor Patrick G, Williams Emily C, Maisto Stephen A, Bryant Kendall J, Fiellin David A
Yale University School of Medicine, 367 Cedar Street, ESH A, New Haven, CT, 06510, USA.
Center for Interdisciplinary Research On AIDS, Yale University School of Public Health, 135 College Street, New Haven, CT, 06510, USA.
Addict Sci Clin Pract. 2016 Jan 13;11(1):1. doi: 10.1186/s13722-015-0048-z.
Effective counseling and pharmacotherapy for unhealthy alcohol use are rarely provided in HIV treatment settings to patients. Our goal was to describe factors influencing implementation of a stepped care model to address unhealthy alcohol use in HIV clinics from the perspectives of social workers, psychologists and addiction psychiatrists.
We conducted two focus groups with Social Workers (n = 4), Psychologists (n = 2), and Addiction Psychiatrists (n = 4) involved in an ongoing randomized controlled trial evaluating the effectiveness of integrated stepped care for unhealthy alcohol use in HIV-infected patients at five Veterans Health Administration (VA) HIV clinics. Data collection and analyses were guided by the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR) domains, with a focus on the three domains which we considered to be most relevant: intervention characteristics (i.e. motivational interviewing, pharmacotherapy), the inner setting (i.e. HIV clinics), and characteristics of individuals (i.e. the providers). A multidisciplinary team used directed content analysis to identify major themes.
From the providers' perspective, the major implementation themes that emerged by CFIR domain included: (1) Intervention characteristics: providers valued tools and processes for facilitating patient motivation for treatment of unhealthy alcohol use given their perceived lack of motivation, but expressed a desire for greater flexibility; (2) Inner setting: treating unhealthy alcohol use in HIV clinics was perceived by providers to be consistent with VA priorities; and (3) Characteristics of individuals: there was high self-efficacy to conduct the intervention, an expressed need for more consistent utilization to maintain skills, and consideration of alternative models for delivering the components of the intervention.
Use of the CFIR framework reveals that implementation of integrated stepped care for unhealthy alcohol use in HIV clinics is facilitated by tools to help providers enhance patient motivation or address unhealthy alcohol use among patients perceived to be unmotivated. Implementation may be facilitated by its consistency with organizational values and existing models of care and attention to optimizing provider self-efficacy and roles (i.e. approaches to treatment integration).
在艾滋病治疗环境中,很少为患者提供针对不健康饮酒行为的有效咨询和药物治疗。我们的目标是从社会工作者、心理学家和成瘾精神科医生的角度,描述影响在艾滋病诊所实施逐步护理模式以解决不健康饮酒问题的因素。
我们与参与一项正在进行的随机对照试验的社会工作者(n = 4)、心理学家(n = 2)和成瘾精神科医生(n = 4)进行了两个焦点小组讨论,该试验评估了在五个退伍军人健康管理局(VA)艾滋病诊所对感染艾滋病病毒患者的不健康饮酒行为进行综合逐步护理的有效性。数据收集和分析以实施研究综合框架(CFIR)领域为指导,重点关注我们认为最相关的三个领域:干预特征(即动机性访谈、药物治疗)、内部环境(即艾滋病诊所)和个人特征(即提供者)。一个多学科团队使用定向内容分析法来确定主要主题。
从提供者的角度来看,CFIR领域出现的主要实施主题包括:(1)干预特征:鉴于提供者认为患者缺乏动机,他们重视有助于促进患者治疗不健康饮酒行为动机的工具和流程,但表示希望有更大的灵活性;(2)内部环境:提供者认为在艾滋病诊所治疗不健康饮酒行为与VA的优先事项一致;(3)个人特征:进行干预的自我效能感较高,明确需要更持续地利用以保持技能,并考虑提供干预组成部分的替代模式。
使用CFIR框架表明,通过帮助提供者增强患者动机或解决被认为缺乏动机的患者中不健康饮酒行为的工具,可促进在艾滋病诊所实施针对不健康饮酒行为的综合逐步护理。其与组织价值观和现有护理模式的一致性以及对优化提供者自我效能和角色(即治疗整合方法)的关注可能有助于实施。