Fisher James M, Rudd Matthew P, Walker Richard W, Stewart Jane
Education Department, Northumbria Healthcare National Health Service Foundation Trust, North Tyneside General Hospital, North Shields, UK.
J Am Geriatr Soc. 2016 Jan;64(1):168-73. doi: 10.1111/jgs.13875.
In recognition of the fact that elder abuse is a global problem that doctors underrecognize and underreport, a simulation training session for undergraduate medical students was developed. The primary objective of this qualitative study was to examine barriers to and drivers of medical students making a diagnosis of elder abuse in simulated practice, with the goal of refining teaching methods and informing future teaching sessions for other clinical teachers. Third-year medical students (Newcastle University, United Kingdom) undertook a simulation scenario with a high-fidelity mannequin representing an elder abuse victim. After the simulation scenario, students underwent a semistructured debriefing. A tripartite approach to data collection was employed that included audio recordings of the simulation, data sheets capturing students' thoughts during the scenario, and postscenario debriefing. A different researcher analyzed each data set in isolation before discussions were held to triangulate findings from the data sets. Forty-six students undertook the scenario; none declined to participate. A number of barriers to students diagnosing elder abuse were identified. Students held a low index of suspicion for elder abuse and were overly optimistic regarding the etiology of the individual's injuries. Students lacked the confidence to raise concerns about possible elder abuse, believing that certainty was required before doing so. There was widespread confusion about nomenclature. These findings provide clinical teachers with important topic areas to address in future teaching sessions. Simulation, as a method to teach about elder abuse in a reproducible and immersive fashion, is recommended to clinical teachers.
鉴于虐待老年人是一个全球问题,医生对此认识不足且报告不足,因此为本科医学生开展了一次模拟培训课程。这项定性研究的主要目的是探讨医学生在模拟实践中诊断虐待老年人的障碍和驱动因素,以完善教学方法并为其他临床教师的未来教学课程提供参考。英国纽卡斯尔大学的三年级医学生参与了一个使用高仿真人体模型模拟虐待老年人受害者的场景。模拟场景结束后,学生们接受了半结构化的汇报。采用了三方数据收集方法,包括模拟过程的音频记录、记录学生在场景中的想法的数据表以及场景后的汇报。在进行讨论以对数据集的结果进行三角验证之前,由不同的研究人员分别分析每个数据集。46名学生参与了该场景;无人拒绝参与。研究确定了学生诊断虐待老年人存在的一些障碍。学生对虐待老年人的怀疑指数较低,对伤者的病因过于乐观。学生缺乏提出对可能存在的虐待老年人问题的担忧的信心,认为在这样做之前需要有确定性。对术语存在广泛的混淆。这些发现为临床教师在未来教学课程中提供了重要的主题领域。建议临床教师采用模拟方法,以可重复且身临其境的方式教授虐待老年人的相关知识。