Varley Rosemary, Cowell Patricia E, Dyson Lucy, Inglis Lesley, Roper Abigail, Whiteside Sandra P
From the Division of Psychology and Language Sciences, University College London, London, United Kingdom (R.V.); Department of Human Communication Sciences, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom (P.E.C., L.D., L.I., S.P.W.); and Division of Language and Communication Science, City University London, London, United Kingdom (A.R.).
Stroke. 2016 Mar;47(3):822-8. doi: 10.1161/STROKEAHA.115.011939. Epub 2016 Jan 21.
There is currently little evidence on effective interventions for poststroke apraxia of speech. We report outcomes of a trial of self-administered computer therapy for apraxia of speech.
Effects of speech intervention on naming and repetition of treated and untreated words were compared with those of a visuospatial sham program. The study used a parallel-group, 2-period, crossover design, with participants receiving 2 interventions. Fifty participants with chronic and stable apraxia of speech were randomly allocated to 1 of 2 order conditions: speech-first condition versus sham-first condition. Period 1 design was equivalent to a randomized controlled trial. We report results for this period and profile the effect of the period 2 crossover.
Period 1 results revealed significant improvement in naming and repetition only in the speech-first group. The sham-first group displayed improvement in speech production after speech intervention in period 2. Significant improvement of treated words was found in both naming and repetition, with little generalization to structurally similar and dissimilar untreated words. Speech gains were largely maintained after withdrawal of intervention. There was a significant relationship between treatment dose and response. However, average self-administered dose was modest for both groups. Future software design would benefit from incorporation of social and gaming components to boost motivation.
Single-word production can be improved in chronic apraxia of speech with behavioral intervention. Self-administered computerized therapy is a promising method for delivering high-intensity speech/language rehabilitation.
URL: http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1278-0601. Unique identifier: ISRCTN88245643.
目前关于中风后言语失用症有效干预措施的证据很少。我们报告了一项针对言语失用症的自我管理计算机疗法试验的结果。
将言语干预对已治疗和未治疗单词的命名和重复的影响与视觉空间假程序的影响进行比较。该研究采用平行组、两阶段交叉设计,参与者接受两种干预。50名患有慢性稳定言语失用症的参与者被随机分配到两种顺序条件中的一种:言语优先条件与假治疗优先条件。第一阶段设计等同于随机对照试验。我们报告此阶段的结果,并描述第二阶段交叉的效果。
第一阶段结果显示,仅在言语优先组中命名和重复有显著改善。假治疗优先组在第二阶段言语干预后言语产生有改善。在命名和重复方面,已治疗单词均有显著改善,但对结构相似和不相似的未治疗单词几乎没有泛化作用。干预撤药后言语改善在很大程度上得以维持。治疗剂量与反应之间存在显著关系。然而,两组的平均自我管理剂量都不大。未来的软件设计若纳入社交和游戏组件以提高动机将有益。
通过行为干预可改善慢性言语失用症中的单字产出。自我管理的计算机化疗法是提供高强度言语/语言康复的一种有前景的方法。
网址:http://orcid.org/0000-0002-1278-0601。唯一标识符:ISRCTN88245643。