Mathieu L, Marty A, Ramaki A, Najib A, Ahmadzai W, Fugazzotto D J, Rigal S, Shirzai N
Department of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, Desgenettes Military Hospital, Lyon, France.
Department of Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, Legouest Military Hospital, Metz, France.
Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg. 2014 Jun;40(3):387-93. doi: 10.1007/s00068-013-0334-y. Epub 2013 Oct 10.
Management practices associated with war-related amputations in countries at war may be different from the recommendations of occidental Health Force Services due to the high numbers of wounded persons to treat in precarious conditions. This observational retrospective study documents the current management of local lower extremity amputees in Afghanistan. Surgical practices, with or without delayed primary closure (DPC), and prosthetic rehabilitation issues are analyzed.
This retrospective study was conducted in the National Military Hospital (NMH) of Kabul from May 2011 to November 2011. Fifty-four Afghan patients who underwent a lower extremity combat-related amputation were included. Ten of them sustained a bilateral amputation.
Injuries were caused by improvised explosive devices (IEDs) or mines in 48 cases, bullets in three cases, and exploding shell fragments in three cases. Of the 64 amputations studied, 46 were open length preserving amputations and primary closure (PC) was applied in 18 cases. Patients were reviewed with a mean follow-up of 5.4 months (range 1-28 months). In the DPC group, secondary closure was performed with a mean time of 18.7 days (range 4-45 days) from injury. The proportion of infectious complications seemed to be higher in the PC group (5/18) than in the DPC group (3/46), but it was only a statistical trend (p = 0.1). Forty-three patients were not prosthetic fitted at the last follow-up.
This study supports the surgical strategy of a two-stage procedure for lower limb amputations in countries at war, but underlines the problems of late secondary closure and prosthetic fitting related to decreased sanitary conditions.
由于在不稳定条件下需要治疗的伤员数量众多,处于战争状态国家中与战争相关截肢的管理做法可能不同于西方卫生部队服务机构的建议。这项观察性回顾性研究记录了阿富汗当地下肢截肢者的当前管理情况。分析了采用或不采用延迟一期缝合(DPC)的手术做法以及假肢康复问题。
这项回顾性研究于2011年5月至2011年11月在喀布尔的国家军事医院(NMH)进行。纳入了54例接受下肢战斗相关截肢的阿富汗患者。其中10例为双侧截肢。
48例损伤由简易爆炸装置(IED)或地雷造成,3例由子弹造成,3例由爆炸弹片造成。在研究的64例截肢中,46例为开放性保肢截肢,18例采用了一期缝合(PC)。对患者进行了平均5.4个月(范围1 - 28个月)的随访。在DPC组中,从受伤到进行二期缝合的平均时间为18.7天(范围4 - 45天)。PC组感染并发症的比例似乎高于DPC组(5/18对比3/46),但这只是一种统计学趋势(p = 0.1)。在最后一次随访时,43例患者未安装假肢。
本研究支持在处于战争状态的国家中对下肢截肢采用两阶段手术策略,但强调了与卫生条件下降相关的二期延迟缝合和假肢安装问题。